indianz.com your internet resource indianz.com on facebook indianz.com on twitter indianz.com on Google+ indianz.com on soundcloud
phone: 202 630 8439
Sovereignty and E-Commerce:  Innovating and Reshaping the  Borders of Indian Country - Arizona State University Third Annual Tribal Government E-Commerce CLE Conference
Advertise on Indianz.Com
Home > News > Headlines
Print   Subscribe
Appeals court backs climbing ban at sacred site
Tuesday, August 28, 2007
Filed Under: Environment | Law

A ban on recreational climbing at Cave Rock, a sacred Washoe site, does not violate the U.S. Constitution, a federal appeals court ruled on Monday.

In a unanimous decision, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals said the U.S. Forest Service acted lawfully when it banned climbing at the site. The three-judge panel cited the historical and cultural importance of Cave Rock not just to the Washoe Tribe, but to the entire country.

"The fact that Cave Rock is a sacred site to the Washoe does not diminish its importance as a national cultural resource," Judge J. Clifford Wallace wrote for the majority.

The decision marks the latest in a string of defeats for The Access Fund, a climbers' group that challenged the ban. The non-profit organization lost an administrative appeal and a lower court ruling.

At issue was whether the Forest Service's management plan for Lake Tahoe, where Cave Rock is located, violates the Constitution's Establishment Clause, which bars the government from favoring one religion over another. The climbers also said the plan was "arbitrary and capricious."

The 9th Circuit rejected the constitutional claim on two grounds. On the first, the court said the Forest Service's climbing ban served a "secular purpose" because it protects the cultural, historical and archaeological features of Cave Rock.

"Historical and cultural considerations motivate the preservation of national monuments that may have religious significance to many or even most visitors," Wallace wrote, comparing Cave Rock's importance to that of National Cathedral in Washington, D.C.

Second, the court said the ban doesn't favor Washoe religious beliefs. In fact, the Forest Service rejected the tribe's contention that all activity, not just climbing, should have been covered in the management plan.

"The Forest Service's chosen alternative not only provides for general public use and access well beyond members of the Washoe Tribe, but also permits activities that are incompatible with Washoe beliefs," the opinion stated.

As for the "arbitrary and capricious" claim, the 9th Circuit rejected the argument that the ban unfairly singles out climbing over other recreational activities. The decision pointed to years of unauthorized drilling and boring by climbers at Cave Rock, which the Washoe Tribe views as a desecration of the site.

"As documented in extensive research and consultation with various community groups, rock climbing harms the physical (not necessarily geological) integrity of the rock," Wallace wrote.

This isn't the first time the 9th Circuit has backed a government policy that protects sacred sites. In September 2004, the court said the state of Arizona acted lawfully by refusing to buy materials that were mined from a sacred Hopi, Navajo and Zuni site.

"Native American sacred sites of historical value are entitled to the same protection as the many Judeo-Christian religious sites," Judge Betty B. Fletcher wrote in a decision that was cited as precedent in the Cave Rock case.

The 9th Circuit heard oral arguments in San Francisco on February 15. Audio of the proceeding is available here.

Get the Decision:
The Access Fund v. USDA (August 27, 2007) |

Relevant Documents:
Cave Rock Record of Decision (August 2003) | Environmental Impact Statement (October 2002)

Relevant Links:
Washoe Tribe - http://www.washoetribe.us
The Access Fund - http://www.accessfund.org
Cave Rock, U.S. Forest Service, - http://www.fs.fed.us/r5/ltbmu/projects/cave-rock

Related Stories:
Washoe Tribe sacred site case heads to 9th Circuit (1/18)
No climbing signs posted at sacred Cave Rock (3/2)
Federal judge upholds ban on climbing at sacred rock (02/01)
Appeals court says sacred sites worthy of protection (09/07)
Climbing group backs voluntary ban at sacred rock (07/06)
Climbers say sacred rock belongs to everyone (04/20)
Climbing group sues over ban at sacred site (12/16)
Forest Service upholds ban on climbing at sacred site (11/11)
Forest Service bans climbing at sacred rock (07/11)

Copyright © Indianz.Com
More headlines...
Stay Connected:
On Facebook

On Twitter

On Google+

On SoundCloud
Local Links:
Federal Register | Indian Gaming | Jobs & Notices | In The Hoop | Message Board
Latest News:
Tribes mount another fight after Trump approves another pipeline (3/24)
Native Sun News Today: Navajo elders continue long fight on land (3/24)
Editorial: Just another day of trying to keep up with the Trumps (3/24)
Elizabeth LaPensée: Video games encourage indigenous culture (3/24)
Mary Annette Pember: Native women work with youth offenders (3/24)
Tiffany Midge: Trump continues to conjure hero Andrew Jackson (3/24)
John Kane: Seneca Nation money train coming to end in New York (3/24)
Grand Ronde Tribes secure approval of school mascot agreement (3/24)
Editorial: Federal recognition for tribes in Virginia is long overdue (3/24)
Seneca Nation ends casino payments after sending $1.4B to state (3/24)
Appeals court hears slew of Indian cases amid focus on nominee (3/23)
Internal tribal disputes continue to trip up federal court system (3/23)
Mark Trahant: Indian health care gains ignored in political debate (3/23)
Native Sun News Today: Young fighters maintain Lakota tradition (3/23)
Ivan Star Comes Out: America loses its self-respect and humanity (3/23)
Rosalyn LaPier: Why water remains sacred to indigenous peoples (3/23)
Winona LaDuke: North Dakota spreads filth about water protectors (3/23)
Harold Monteau: Tribal governments are abusing their own people (3/23)
Alex Jacobs: Donald Trump in middle of the 'deep state civil war' (3/23)
Secretary Zinke announces 'doggy days' for Interior Department (3/23)
Keystone XL Pipeline route crosses Ponca Tribe's forced removal (3/23)
Indian lawmaker resigns after being charged for child prostitution (3/23)
Pinoleville Pomo Nation buys site of long-delayed casino project (3/23)
High court pick acknowledges poor treatment of 'sovereign' tribes (3/22)
Dakota Access submits another status update entirely under seal (3/22)
Court allows claim for alleged underpayment in Cobell settlement (3/22)
South Dakota tribes continue to extend Class III gaming compacts (3/22)
Cowlitz Tribe secures approval to offer liquor as casino debut nears (3/22)
Native Sun News Today: Community project continues at Pine Ridge (3/22)
Cronkite News: Copper mine on sacred site complains about delays (3/22)
Mary Annette Pember: Awareness for missing and murdered sisters (3/22)
Stacy Pratt: Visiting the gravesite of Andrew Jackson in Tennessee (3/22)
Murder charge filed for fatal shooting of Navajo Nation police officer (3/22)
Muckleshoot Tribe still seeking answers for fatal shooting by officer (3/22)
Hopland Band submits claim for county raid of marijuana operation (3/22)
Chukchansi Tribe sued for $21M by gaming development company (3/22)
Seminole Tribe accused of breaking contract with outlet at casino (3/22)
Indian Child Welfare Act survives attack from conservative groups (3/21)
Senate Committee on Indian Affairs schedules hearing on diabetes (3/21)
Ponca Tribe hosts 282-mile walk to retrace trail of forced removal (3/21)
more headlines...

Home | Arts & Entertainment | Business | Canada | Cobell Lawsuit | Education | Environment | Federal Recognition | Federal Register | Forum | Health | Humor | Indian Gaming | Indian Trust | Jack Abramoff Scandal | Jobs & Notices | Law | National | News | Opinion | Politics | Sports | Technology | World

Indianz.Com Terms of Service | Indianz.Com Privacy Policy
About Indianz.Com | Advertise on Indianz.Com

Indianz.Com is a product of Noble Savage Media, LLC and Ho-Chunk, Inc.