Law
Court upholds state jurisdiction on Meskwaki lands


The state of Iowa has criminal and civil jurisdiction on Meskwaki tribal lands, the Iowa Supreme Court ruled on Friday.

In a unanimous decision [Link], the court said tribal members can be charged with violating state laws becuse the state has authority on the reservation under an act of Congress. The court, however, adopted a test to determine whether a state law is criminal/prohibitory or civil/regulatory in nature.

If the law is criminal/prohibitory, then the state has jursdiction, the court said. But if it is civil/regulatory, the state doesn't under the Cabazon decision from the U.S. Supreme Court.

In this instance, the Iowa court ruled that a tribal employee can be charged for selling tobacco to a minor. The tribe argued that the law was civil in nature but the court held that it was criminal.

In related Meskwaki news, the security company has asked a federal judge to force the tribe into arbitration. The company signed a contract with the tribe's former chairman who was later ousted after a leadership dispute.

Get the Story:
Tribal land not exempt from law, court says (The Des Moines Register 10/29)
Security company seeks arbitration of Meskwaki contract (AP 10/29)
pwlat

Related Stories:
Meskwaki Tribe working with ex-Abramoff associate (09/07)
Meskwakis gave $50K to group founded by Norton (04/22)
Lawsuit over Meskwaki Tribe's leadership dismissed (03/03)
Meskwaki Tribe starts court to resolve internal disputes (09/06)
Rival factions of Meskwaki Tribe still feuding (01/22)
BIA reaffirms result of Meskwaki Tribe's election (12/19)
Meskwaki Tribe confirms delay in casino re-opening (11/20)
Bank wants court to rule on Meskwaki Tribe's funds (11/17)
Meskwaki voters replace four who were recalled (11/06)
Ousted Meskwaki leader claims election is illegal (10/28)
BIA to recognize results of Meskwaki election (10/22)
Another vote set for Meskwaki Tribe leadership (10/21)
Bear faction takes most votes in Meskwaki primary (10/16)
BIA will look at two Meskwaki Tribe elections (10/15)
Location of Meskwaki Tribe primary in dispute (10/13)
Meskwaki members nominate nine for recall (10/08)
Meskwaki factions still far apart on leadership (10/3)
Confusion reigns as Meskwaki takeover fails (10/2)
Elected Meskwaki council tries to retake casino (10/1)
Meskwakis using federal funds to pay attorneys (9/16)
Meskwaki casino shutdown extended by NIGC (9/12)
Appeals court sides with NIGC on casino shutdown (08/28)
Iowa county says it will evict Meskwaki rivals (08/18)
DOI judge says Meskwaki casino should reopen (08/13)
BIA calls on Meskwaki Tribe to hold recall election (08/06)
Meskwaki factions ask court to reopen casino (07/25)
Meskwaki factions and NIGC head to court on casino (7/24)
Appeals court holding hearing on Meskwaki casino (07/09)
Meskwaki dispute centers on recall petitions (7/7)
Meskwaki faction agrees to create election board (7/3)
Meskwaki faction votes to oust law firm (6/27)
Meskwaki faction says BIA agreed to election (6/23)
DOI meeting with Meskwaki Tribe canceled (6/20)
DOI to discuss Meskwaki leadership dispute (6/19)
Editorial: Don't interfere in tribal affairs (6/19)
Meskwaki faction wants to fire rival law firm (6/10)
8th Circuit court won't reopen Meswaki casino (05/30)
8th Circuit reviewing Meskwaki casino shutdown (5/28)
BIA won't recognize Meskwaki Tribe election (5/27)
Federal marshals close Meskwaki Tribe's casino (5/23)
Meskwaki voters asked to choose new leaders (5/22)
Meskwaki voters urged to vote for new council (5/21)
NIGC asks court to close Meskwaki Tribe's casino (5/20)
Judge calls for receivership for Meskwaki funds (5/19)
Meskwaki casino stays open during leadership spat (5/15)
NIGC orders Meskwaki Tribe to close casino (5/14)
State threatens Meskwaki compact over dispute (5/9)
Meskwaki factions can't agree on discussions (5/8)
Talks between Meskwaki leaders break down (5/6)
Meskwaki Tribe works to resolve dispute (5/5)
NIGC says Meskwaki Tribe in violation of IGRA (5/1)
Meskwaki leadership dispute continues (4/30)
Editorial: NIGC should interfere in tribal dispute (04/24)
NIGC threatens to close Meskwaki Tribe's casino (4/23)
Meskwaki leadership dispute won't affect payroll (4/18)
Federal judge won't intervene in Meskwaki dispute (4/16)
Meskwaki Tribe undergoing leadership struggle (4/10)
Meskwaki tribal council removed and replaced (03/27)