indianz.com your internet resource indianz.com on facebook indianz.com on twitter indianz.com on Google+
ph: 202 630 8439   fax: 202 318 2182
Kill The Tobacco Master Settlement Agreement
Advertise on Indianz.Com
Home > News > Headlines
Print   Subscribe
Michigan tribe wins gaming rights case
Tuesday, September 2, 2008
Filed Under: Law | National

A Michigan tribe whose casino was threatened by a bureaucratic blunder won its case against the federal government on Friday.

The Sault Ste. Marie Tribe of Chippewa Indians spent $41 million on the Kewadin Shores Casino in order to replace an aging facility with health and safety problems. But the National Indian Gaming Commission said the site in the city of St. Ignace did not qualify for gaming under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act.

Facing economic uncertainty, the tribe took the government to court and won a preliminary injunction that allowed the casino to open for the busy Labor Day weekend in 2007. A year later, a federal judge rewarded the tribe with a final decision that upholds the legality of the site.

In the 37-page ruling, Judge R. Allan Edgar said the government "dropped the ball" by failing to resolve a bureaucratic blunder dating to 1986 that would have prevented the litigation altogether. He said the casino site qualifies for gaming because it is "contiguous" to an existing reservation, as allowed by IGRA.

"Defendants appear to ignore any case law that discusses the meaning of reservation in any context and instead rely on their own inability to make a decision on a timely request for a proclamation as evidence of the lack of merit of the request," Edgar wrote.

IGRA generally bars gaming on land taken into trust after 1988 unless certain exceptions are met. The Kewadin Shores site was acquired in 2000, well past the IGRA deadline.

The tribe argued that the site qualifies because it is contiguous to land that was placed in trust 1983, long before the passage of IGRA. The tribe even asked the Bureau of Indian Affairs for a proclamation to declare the 1983 parcel a reservation in 1986, two years before IGRA became law.

Despite the history, the NIGC issued a series of opinions that said the 1983 site was not a reservation. Attorneys from the Interior Department weighed in and said the only way for the 1983 site to be considered a reservation was for the BIA to formally declare it to be one.

The government's stance meant the 2000 parcel could not be used for gaming without going through an additional, lengthy review process that only three tribes have completed in the history of IGRA.

But Edgar said the BIA's inaction shouldn't be held against the tribe. He said ambiguities in the definition of "reservation" tipped the case in the tribe's favor.

Edgar noted that the BIA's recent IGRA regulations appear to bring some certainty to the issue. The Section 20 rules, however, were finalized long after the tribe applied for its reservation proclamation, he said.

As a result, "this court must review the defendants' actions at the time of the decision, not in hindsight," Edgar wrote.

A similar case involving the Fort Sill Apache Tribe of Oklahoma is pending in federal court. The tribe asked the BIA for a reservation proclamation for land held in trust in New Mexico.

The BIA failed to act on the proclamation even as the tribe moved forward with plans for a gaming facility. A judge has so far declined to force the BIA to make a decision.

Court Decisions:
Final Judgement (August 29, 2008) | Preliminary Injunction (August 28, 2007)

Court Documents:
Magistrate's Report (July 23, 2007) | Government's Objections (August 6, 2007)

DOI Documents:
NIGC Opinion (February 14, 2006) | David Bernhardt Letter (July 26, 2006) | NIGC Opinion (July 31, 2006) | NIGC Final Decision (September 1, 2006) | Carl Artman Letter (December 8, 2006) George Skibine Testimony (June 13, 2007)

Related Stories:
Judge won't force BIA to act on Fort Sill Apache site (8/8)
NIGC cites 'broken promises' in ruling against casino (5/22)
Artman issues gaming rules as he leaves BIA ofice (5/20)
Michigan tribe set to open casino after court victory (8/29)
Gaming rules behind schedule, BIA head confirms (8/13)
Judge hits BIA on Chickasaw Nation gaming site (7/19)
Judge orders Indian land determination on casino (7/18)
House panel takes up land-into-trust, recognition bills (6/14)
BIA continues work on gaming land regulation (12/04)
Another GAO report looks at land-into-trust (10/25)
GAO finds lengthy delays on land-into-trust (8/28)
Legislation won't address all land-into-trust issues (04/05)
Off-reservation casino sites still in question (3/16)
BIA sets timetable for new gaming regulations (03/01)
Senate panel presses BIA on gaming regulations (02/02)
BIA takes stab at land-into-trust for gaming rules (2/1)



Copyright © Indianz.Com
More headlines...
Local Links:
Federal Register | Indian Gaming | Jobs & Notices | In The Hoop | Message Board
Latest News:
Native Sun News: Keystone XL Pipeline foes headed to DC (4/21)
Native Sun News: Shoni Schimmel is a role model for youth (4/21)
Michell Hicks: Eastern Cherokees return to gardening roots (4/21)
Kiara Imani Williams: Tribal ID dismissed in nation's capital (4/21)
DOI looks to spend $2.55M on Makah Nation land buy-back (4/21)
Pascua Yaqui Tribe faces a test of jurisdiction under VAWA (4/21)
State Department needs more time to review Keystone XL (4/21)
Aquinnah Wampanoag Tribe cites ruling in gaming lawsuit (4/21)
Column: Cowlitz Tribe casino a bad gamble for community (4/21)
Native Sun News: Oglala Sioux Tribe battles uranium mine (4/18)
Clara Caufield: BIA audits Northern Cheyenne police force (4/18)
10th Circuit affirms conviction for murder of Arapaho man (4/18)
Jay Daniels: Cobell settlement was flawed from beginning (4/18)
Dwanna Robertson: Muscogee Nation returns to homeland (4/18)
Peter d'Errico: Washington team makes colonial invasion (4/18)
Northern Arapaho Tribe receives $157M trust settlement (4/18)
Agua Caliente Band leaseholders seek $7M in tax refunds (4/18)
Oneida Nation sends $11M to county as part of settlement (4/18)
JPR: Klamath Tribes want Congress to approve water deal (4/18)
Judge dismisses Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe election suit (4/18)
ASU News: Navajo students enjoy learning their language (4/18)
Former NFL player jailed for DUI on Salt River Reservation (4/18)
BIA advances off-reservation casino projects in California (4/18)
Tunica-Biloxi Tribe reportedly operating casino at net loss (4/18)
Cherokee Nation to break ground on new hotel with casino (4/18)
Shoshone-Bannock Tribes not planing to offer poker games (4/18)
Arizona tribes close to $1B mark in gaming revenue sharing (4/18)
Group opposes Catawba Nation casino bid in North Carolina (4/18)
Native Sun News: Guilty verdict in death of Lower Brule boy (4/17)
Native Sun News: Paper brings home four first place awards (4/17)
Doug George-Kanentiio: Governor carries on divisive tactics (4/17)
Navajo president criticizes NIGA for withdrawing from event (4/17)
Crystal Willcuts: NFL trickster speaks with a crooked tongue (4/17)
Opinion: NFL team owner flashes money to defend racial slur (4/17)
Ten reservations account for biggest share of Cobell buyback (4/17)
Rosebud Sioux Tribe opposes megaloads through reservation (4/17)
Indian artists seek more control over popular annual market (4/17)
Panel to look into death of pregnant Indian woman in Mexico (4/17)
Lynn Valbuena returns to chairman post at San Manuel Band (4/17)
Yale University museum accused of stealing Tlingit artifacts (4/17)
Navajo Nation Council speaker still on leave amid court fight (4/17)
BIA asked to invalidate Shinnecock Nation's new constitution (4/17)
Onondaga Nation is negotiations over tobacco taxation issue (4/17)
Sen. Warren addresses Native American controversy in book (4/17)
Race relations council looking to boost efforts in border town (4/17)
Opinion: Federal recognition for Virginia tribes long overdue (4/17)
Opinion: University must eventually eliminate Ute nickname (4/17)
Appeals court in Canada rules for Metis in Indian status caes (4/17)
9th Circuit hears dispute over Redding Rancheria gaming site (4/17)
more headlines...

Home | Arts & Entertainment | Business | Canada | Cobell Lawsuit | Education | Environment | Federal Recognition | Forum | Health | Humor | Indian Gaming | Indian Trust | Jack Abramoff Scandal | Jobs & Notices | Law | National | News | Opinion | Politics | Sports | Technology | World

Indianz.Com Terms of Service | Indianz.Com Privacy Policy
About Indianz.Com | Advertise on Indianz.Com

Indianz.Com is a product of Noble Savage Media, LLC and Ho-Chunk, Inc.