Home > News > Headlines

printer friendly version
Off-reservation casinos a concern at gaming summit
Wednesday, March 30, 2005

The controversy surrounding off-reservation gaming has been blown out of proportion, a leading gambling law expert said on Tuesday.

I. Nelson Rose, a Whittier Law School professor, was the opening presenter at the Western Governors' Association summit on Indian gaming in Denver, Colorado. He provided an overview of gambling in the U.S., ending with the rise of the $18 billion tribal casino industry.

"Tribal gambling, casino gambling on reservations is truly big business in America," Rose told attendees of the two-day conference.

Despite the incredible growth of Indian gaming from modest bingo halls to some of the world's largest facilities, Rose said critics have little worry when it comes to off-reservation gaming. While there appears to be a lot of reservation "shopping" going on across the country there is little reservation "buying," he said.

"Reservation shopping is not a real threat," Rose insisted.

That view clashed with others at the summit, attended by representatives of 23 tribes, five tribal organizations, nearly a dozen states and countless casino developers and critics of Indian gaming. Colorado Gov Bill Owens (R), the chair of the WGA, raised the issue early on.

"Here in Colorado, we've had a controversial proposal," he said at a press conference. He accused two Oklahoma tribes and their financial backers of circumventing the state by seeking Congressional approval for a casino outside of Denver.

Two tribal representatives also sounded the alarm. Keller George, the president of the United South and Eastern Tribes, and Kurt Luger, the executive director of the Great Plains Indian Gaming Association, criticized tribes and non-Indian developers for trying to expand gaming beyond existing reservation boundaries.

"There is no precedent for this type of activity," George said at a panel discussion on the growth of Indian gaming. He said off-reservation casino proposals in a dozen states represent a type of "portable sovereignty" that is dangerous to other tribes and erodes state-tribal relations.

Luger, who testified earlier this month at a Congressional hearing on the subject, said off-reservation casinos pose a threat to tribal self-sufficiency "The original intent of the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act is jobs," he said, referring to the need to reduce high rates of unemployment and poverty in Indian Country.

Rose acknowledged the growing number of tribes seeking casinos in urban areas and even in other states. But he said it is extremely rare for the federal government to approve such proposals due to local opposition.

"If you do put up barriers, it almost certainly will not happen," he said.

The debate continues this morning when the summit convenes with a panel on land-into-trust process for off-reservation casinos. George Skibine, the acting deputy assistant secretary for policy and economic development at the Bureau of Indian Affairs, is scheduled to present.

Also on the panel are Luger, South Dakota attorney general Larry Long, who is fighting the Lower Brule Sioux Tribe's land-into-trust request, Steve Hillard, a developer associated with the proposed Cheyenne-Arapaho casino in Colorado, and George Epp, the executive director of the Colorado Sheriffs Association.

Relevant Links:
NIGC Indian Land Determinations - http://www.nigc.gov/nigc/nigcControl?option=LAND_DETERMINATIONS
Land into Trust, National Congress of American Indians - http://www.ncai.org/main/pages/issues/
governance/land_into_trust.asp
Western Governors' Association, Gaming Summit - http://www.westgov.org/wga/meetings/gaming.htm

Related Stories:
Exceptions to rule in Indian gaming law more common (3/21)
California tribe kills off-reservation casino plan (3/21)
Off-reservation concerns aired at House hearing (3/18)
Off-reservation gaming hearing set by Pombo (3/15)
Congress steps into off-reservation casino fight (3/14)
Pombo circulates draft of off-reservation bill (3/11)
McCain takes on controversial topics in 109th Congress (03/07)
States asking too much of tribes, leaders say (02/16)
Off-reservation casinos spur action in California (01/28)
California tribes face divisions on key issues (01/27)
Pombo took on controversial topics in 108th Congress (12/16)
Agencies still in conflict over off-reservation gaming (12/07)
Out-of-state claim dismissed by federal judge (12/3)
Oklahoma tribe settles land claim for New York casino (11/15)
BIA still hasn't ruled on out-of-state land acquisition (11/11)
Colorado governor rejects casino for out-of-state tribes (09/09)
Judge backs Oklahoma tribe's claim in New York (09/02)
Oklahoma tribes lead pack in out-of-state land claims (08/16)
BIA caught in debate over off-reservation gaming (07/14)
House committee hearing tackles tough topic (7/13)
BIA official promises policy on off-reservation gaming (06/30)
Court upholds off-reservation gaming provision in IGRA (04/30)
BIA official warns of Congressional maneuvering (04/16)
IGRA amendments mired in debate over revenues (04/13)
Tribes take chances with far-away land acquisitions (04/01)
NIGC rules against Okla. tribe's casino in Kansas (03/26)
Senate panel debates changes to Indian gaming act (03/25)
Appeals court rules in 'reservation shopping' dispute (11/17)
Calif. tribe moving forward with urban casino plans (10/10)
Landless tribe in limbo due to court fight (08/07)
Battle over urban casino continues (07/30)
Clinton signs a final Indian bill (12/29)

Copyright © 2000-2005 Indianz.Com