"Immigration reform is about two things: our nation's values and the economy. Forget the first -- save the debate about principle for another day -- and explore some of the economic impacts.
In a narrow sense, immigration reform proposals might as well be called business reform bills because of the way they create a new regulatory landscape. This will be as true for large corporations as it for mom-and-pop shops.
Business has always been an executor of government policy. Beginning in ancient Egypt, business acted as a tax collector, carrying out the government's need for revenue by adding a sales tax to goods or services. Businesses pay a minimum wage as required by legislation. And, for most of this past century, employer-based health care has replaced the public health role carried out by governments in other industrial nations.
Business already is the government when it implements policy or collects taxes. But should business also enforce immigration law? You could argue that business already does when it benefits from an increased labor pool. Many industries, such as construction, rely on migrant workers.
The Council on Foreign Relations published a paper recently, "The Economic Logic of Illegal Immigration," which quantified the net economic impact as "modest." On one hand, consumers benefited from illegal immigration at about .03 percent of gross domestic product, while there was a small increase in the government benefits paid to illegal immigrants. "Given the uncertainties surrounding this sort of calculation, one could not say with much confidence that this impact is statistically distinguishable from zero," wrote Gordon Hanson, a professor of economics at the University of California-San Diego.
"From an economic perspective," Hanson wrote, "the question for policymakers becomes whether the cost of halting immigration would significantly outweigh the possible benefits.""
Get the Story:
Dollars and sense of illegal immigration
(The Seattle Post-Intelligencer 5/27)
More Mark Trahant:
Mark Trahant: The changing face of America
(5/21)
Mark Trahant: Agree to
disagree about warming (5/7)
Mark
Trahant: Optimism for the newspaper business (4/30)
Mark Trahant: Tribal colleges effective and
essential (4/23)
Mark Trahant: The
global warming debate (4/16)
Mark
Trahant: America's cycles of boom and bust (4/9)
Mark Trahant: Spring cleaning for the government
(3/26)
Mark Trahant: The state of the
changing news media (3/19)
Mark Trahant:
Mismanagement of the Indian trust (3/12)
Mark Trahant: More gloomy prospects for economy
(3/5)
Mark Trahant: An important vote for
Seattle (2/26)
Mark Trahant: America
headed toward credit meltdown (2/19)
Mark Trahant: Doom and gloom on global warming
(2/12)
Mark Trahant: Americans unsettled
over economy (2/5)
Mark Trahant: Too
hard to ignore global warming (1/22)
Mark Trahant: Women finally take their place
(1/15)
Mark Trahant: Raise taxes to pay
for war in Iraq (1/8)
Mark Trahant:
President Gerald Ford and Indian health (1/2)
Mark Trahant: Congress finds time to do nothing
(12/11)
Mark Trahant: Wake up America
and smell the bills (12/4)
Mark Trahant:
States seek 'share' of tribal cash (11/20)
Mark Trahant: Critics wrong on affirmative
action (11/06)
Mark Trahant: Yet another
column on economics (10/30)
Mark
Trahant: Voters look at the bigger picture (10/23)
Mark Trahant: Governments lie because politicians
lie (10/16)
Mark Trahant: Americans know
spending out of control (10/9)
Mark
Trahant: Washington ignores huge debt (10/2)
Mark Trahant: Generation tested by challenges
(9/25)
Mark Trahant: The bubble bursts
on our credit (9/18)
Mark Trahant:
Forget the rethoric about Iran (9/11)
Mark Trahant: Everyone can't be that good (9/5)
Mark Trahant: Immigration reform only
solution (8/28)
Mark Trahant: What if
scenarios of terror attacks (8/21)
Mark
Trahant: Finding common ground on the issues (8/14)
Mark Trahant: A government program that works???
(8/7)
Mark Trahant: The anxious state of
the economy (7/31)
Mark Trahant: An
Internet-based democracy (7/24)
Mark
Trahant: It's time for the U.S. to keep its word (7/17)
Mark Trahant: Immigration a solution for work force
(7/10)
Mark Trahant: No economic
paradise in America (06/12)
Mark
Trahant: What went wrong at Fannie Mae? (6/5)
Mark Trahant: A hip, cool place in Washington DC
(5/29)
Mark Trahant: Border fence a bad
idea for U.S. (5/22)
Mark Trahant: It's
time for U.S. and Iran to talk (5/15)
Mark Trahant: High gas prices a wake-up call to
America (5/8)
Mark Trahant: Stark
choices define American politics (5/1)
Mark Trahant: Hope for the best, plan for the worst
(4/24)
Trahant: We should decide how our
taxes are spent (4/17)
Mark Trahant:
Entering the immigration debate (4/3)
Mark Trahant: America is a blending of cultures
(3/27)
Mark Trahant: Unsaid debates
dominate agenda (3/20)
Mark Trahant:
Bush and human rights in Pakistan (3/13)
Mark Trahant: Hank Adams, Indian visionary
(3/6)
Mark Trahant: Health care spending
on the rise (2/27)
Mark Trahant: Future
taxpayers will cough up dough (2/13)
Mark Trahant: Sooner or later, America will go
broke (2/6)
Mark Trahant: Bush will tell
us everything is great (1/30)
Mark
Trahant: Abramoff turning into blame the Indians (1/23)
Mark Trahant: Cultural changes come, some slowly
(1/9)
Mark Trahant: Starting new year
off with correction (1/4)
Mark Trahant:
How about a coin for Vine Deloria? (12/19)
Mark Trahant: The really great state of the economy
(12/12)
Mark Trahant: America's numbers
don't add up (12/5)
Mark Trahant: Few
writers as powerful as Deloria (11/21)
Mark Trahant: Media sometimes isn't fair
(11/14)
Mark Trahant: No one wants to talk
about immigration (11/7)
Mark Trahant:
The ultimate power of the Fed (10/31)
Mark Trahant: Is there no trust in the government?
(10/24)
Mark Trahant: The next pick for
Federal Reserve job (10/10)
Mark
Trahant: I was wrong about voting by mail (9/26)
Mark Trahant: Rebuilding New Orleans, a unique city
(9/19)
Mark Trahant: Katrina testing
limits of charity (9/12)
Mark Trahant:
Democracy an unfinished experiment (08/29)
Mark Trahant: You write the news, you pick it
(8/15)
Mark Trahant: Tribal stories
don't matter to science (8/8)
Mark
Trahant: Congress focuses on real issues (8/1)
Mark Trahant: Judicial debate conceals big issue
(7/25)
Mark Trahant: Wasting time at
work can be productive (7/18)
Mark
Trahant: Appoint Indian to U.S. Supreme Court (7/11)
Mark Trahant: Readers offer junk mail solutions
(06/20)
Mark Trahant: Junk mail invades
home, office (6/13)
Mark Trahant: Social
Security needs new compact (6/6)
Mark
Trahant: Readers upset over military cartoon (5/30)
Mark Trahant: Healing the world with totem poles
(5/23)
Mark Trahant: We're all as young
as we feel (5/16)
Mark Trahant: Social
Security debate masks failures (5/9)
Mark Trahant: Public sees bias in the news media
(5/2)
Mark Trahant: Few salmon left for
tribal ceremonies (4/25)
Mark Trahant:
Tax system unfair and complicated (4/18)
Mark Trahant: Our nation must pay its own tax bill
(4/11)
Mark Trahant: Latest numbers on
economy scare me (4/4)
Mark Trahant:
C-SPAN just as important today (3/28)
Mark Trahant: Does democracy mean supporting Bush?
(3/21)
Mark Trahant: Academic freedom
for Churchill too? (03/07)
Mark Trahant:
Journalism more interactive than before (2/28)
Mark Trahant: Social Security debate all about 'me'
(2/21)
Mark Trahant: Social Security
push ignores big issue (2/14)
Mark
Trahant: Human beings only react during crisis (2/7)
Mark Trahant: Election tales usually one-sided
(1/31)
Trahant: Public school system not
good enough (01/24)
Mark Trahant: Three
cheers for the First Amendment (01/10)
Mark Trahant: Did my vote count? Did yours?
(12/20)
Mark Trahant: Bush plan leaves no
room for salmon (12/13)
Mark Trahant:
Two friendly faces on the news (11/29)
Mark Trahant: Mainstream media doesn't matter
(11/22)
Mark Trahant: Do political
endorsements matter? (11/8)
Mark
Trahant: So what happens after the election? (11/1)
Mark Trahant: Vote early and avoid campaign sleaze
(10/25)
Mark Trahant: Congress should
abide by laws too (10/18)
Mark Trahant:
Election changing as we speak (10/11)
Mark Trahant: NMAI must change the story
(09/27)
Mark Trahant: Media's view of
elections should change (09/20)
Mark
Trahant: What happened to Pakistan? bin Laden? (09/13)
Mark Trahant: Payroll tax not fair to all Americans
(8/23)
Mark Trahant: Bush's answer was
slightly better (8/9)
Audio: Bush
explains meaning of tribal sovereignty (8/6)
Mark Trahant: The one that didn't get away
(08/02)
Mark Trahant: Living in a world of
easy credit (7/26)
Mark Trahant:
Congress still stealing Indian land (07/12)
Mark Trahant: Raising the next peace generation
(7/6)
Mark Trahant: How far does
'terrorist' definition go? (6/28)
Mark
Trahant: The big five-oh a good time to reflect (6/21)
Mark Trahant: Ordinary Reagan was extraordinary
(06/14)
Mark Trahant: Indian girls team had
game back in 1900s (06/07)
Mark Trahant:
Voice mail filled with views on Iraqi war (05/17)
Mark Trahant: A familiar story of cultural
change (03/22)
Mark Trahant: One
Indian in Senate is wrong number (03/08)
Mark Trahant: Division marked another major war
too (2/23)
Mark Trahant: We're still
fighting the Cold War (01/26)
Trahant: Selling democracy to Indian
Country (11/17)
Trahant: Can't trust
Uncle Sam with Indian money (11/10)
Mark Trahant: Bush needs to note success and
failure (10/20)
Mark Trahant:
Technology and the news world (09/29)
Mark Trahant: Preparing for the unthinkable
(09/22)
Trahant: When tribes succeed,
someone changes rules (09/1)
Advertisement
Tags
Trending in News
1 White House Council on Native American Affairs meets quick demise under Donald Trump
2 'A process of reconnecting': Young Lakota actor finds ways to stay tied to tribal culture
3 Jenni Monet: Bureau of Indian Affairs officer on leave after fatal shooting of Brandon Laducer
4 'A disgraceful insult': Joe Biden campaign calls out Navajo leader for Republican speech
5 Kaiser Health News: Sisters from Navajo Nation died after helping coronavirus patients
2 'A process of reconnecting': Young Lakota actor finds ways to stay tied to tribal culture
3 Jenni Monet: Bureau of Indian Affairs officer on leave after fatal shooting of Brandon Laducer
4 'A disgraceful insult': Joe Biden campaign calls out Navajo leader for Republican speech
5 Kaiser Health News: Sisters from Navajo Nation died after helping coronavirus patients
More Headlines
Tim Giago: A disease that ravages Indian Country and America
EPA unveils Western office to focus on abandoned mine tracking, cleanup
Following McGirt decision, Oneida Nation case continues string of Indigenous court victories
Clara Caufield: Enduring the COVID Pandemic
Native Sun News Today: Authorities target traffickers during Sturgis rally
Elizabeth Cook-Lynn: A state of war?
Native Sun News Today: 'Sovereignty is Real'
Native youth navigate complex, contradictory jurisdictions
President of Oglala Sioux Tribe suspended ahead of impeachment hearing
'A process of reconnecting': Young Lakota actor finds ways to stay tied to tribal culture
White House Council on Native American Affairs meets quick demise under Donald Trump
Tribes, Nevada Guard combine efforts for COVID-19 testing
More Headlines
EPA unveils Western office to focus on abandoned mine tracking, cleanup
Following McGirt decision, Oneida Nation case continues string of Indigenous court victories
Clara Caufield: Enduring the COVID Pandemic
Native Sun News Today: Authorities target traffickers during Sturgis rally
Elizabeth Cook-Lynn: A state of war?
Native Sun News Today: 'Sovereignty is Real'
Native youth navigate complex, contradictory jurisdictions
President of Oglala Sioux Tribe suspended ahead of impeachment hearing
'A process of reconnecting': Young Lakota actor finds ways to stay tied to tribal culture
White House Council on Native American Affairs meets quick demise under Donald Trump
Tribes, Nevada Guard combine efforts for COVID-19 testing
More Headlines