U.S. Supreme Court nominee Samuel Alito ruled in favor of an alleged Indian "holy man" who fought state officials over the right to exercise his religion.
As a judge on the 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals, Alito authored the opinion in Blackhawk v. Pennsylvania. The case involved Dennis L. Blackhawk, a Pennsylvania man who keeps two black bears in his backyard and uses them for ceremonies [Indianz.Com: Judge allows unrecognized Indian protection].
"Members of various American Indian tribes visit Blackhawk from across the country to participate in these rituals. Due to Blackhawk's stewardship of the bears and his role in these ceremonies, some consider him to be a holy man,' Alito wrote in August 20, 2004, decision [PDF].
The state of Pennsylvania didn't view Blackhawk that way and game officials ordered him to pay a fee to keep the bears. He sought a waiver, which was denied, and the state sought to confiscate Timber and Tundra when he failed to pay the fee.
Upholding a lower court judge, Alito ruled that the state violated Blackhawk's constitutional rights in denying the waiver. He said the state fee scheme couldn't withstand a "strict scrutiny" review because exceptions are allowed in some cases.
Blackhawk claims to be Lenape (Delaware) but is not enrolled in any tribe. Alito didn't take up the issue of Indian heritage but referred to it in explaining Blackhawk's religious needs.
"Lakota Indians believe that black bears protect the Earth, sanctify religious ceremonies, and imbue worshipers with spiritual strength. Although Blackhawk is a Lenape Indian by birth, he was adopted by elders of the Oglala Lakota and Seneca tribes, who schooled him in the religious traditions of the Lakota and Iroquois people," Alito wrote. "When Blackhawk began to see bears in a recurring dream, Lakota tribal elders concluded that the dream was a prophesy and predicted that Blackhawk would derive spiritual power from the animals."
In an opinion piece for The New York Times, Ann Althouse, a law professor at the University of Wisconsin, argues that decision shows Alito "displayed a sensitivity to the needs of adherents of minority religions" unlike Justice Antonin Scalia. Alito has often been compared to Scalia, who has consistently ruled against tribal interests. Althouse notes that Scalia wrote the decision in
Employment Division v. Smith, which allowed the state of Oregon to go after members of the Native American Church who use peyote.
Related Story:
Ann Althouse: Separated at the Bench
(The New York Times 11/1)
pwnyt
Relevant Links:
Judicial Nominations, White House - http://www.whitehouse.gov/infocus/judicialnominees
Related Stories:
Bush announces new U.S. Supreme Court pick
(10/31)
Failed nominee Miers cited more Indian law work
(10/28)
Miers withdraws
Supreme Court nomination (10/27)
Miers, in speech, supported 'self-determination'
(10/26)
Bush draws 'red line' over Miers
White House papers (10/25)
Democrat says
Miers lacks votes to be confirmed (10/24)
Miers blasted for responses to Senate questionnaire
(10/20)
Supreme Court nominee Miers
cites tribal experience (10/19)
Bush to
tout Miers' knowledge of tribal sovereignty (10/17)
Supreme Court nominee Miers backed gaming limits
(10/12)
U.S. Supreme Court nominee's
gaming work at issue (10/07)
Supreme
Court pick described as loyal, dedicated (10/4)
Bush names woman as O'Connor's replacement
(10/3)
Roberts confirmed and sworn in as
chief justice (9/30)
Bush said to be
near new pick for Supreme Court (9/29)
Senate committee approves Roberts by 13-5 vote
(9/23)
Sen. Leahy announces vote for
Roberts confirmation (9/22)
Sen. Reid to
vote against Roberts nomination (9/21)
Roberts mentions Indian law work on final day
(9/19)
Supreme Court nominee Roberts
promises 'no agenda' (9/13)
Roberts set
for Supreme Court confirmation hearings (9/12)
Native Hawaiian work an issue for Roberts (9/7)
Roberts tapped for chief justice position
(9/6)
Roberts aided O'Connor in
confirmation process (08/11)
Rehnquist
makes brief visit to hospital for fever (08/05)
Confirmation hearings on Roberts to start Sept. 6
(8/1)
Opinion: What does Roberts think
about Seminole? (7/27)
Reagan-era
documents from Roberts released (7/27)
White House plans to release most Roberts papers
(7/26)
NARF lawyer fears Roberts will
lean conservative (07/21)
Bush names
John G. Roberts to Supreme Court (7/20)
Schumer asked about Roberts' views on Natives
(7/20)
Rehnquist slaps down retirement
rumors (7/15)
NCAI's Hall on picking a
Supreme Court justice (7/13)
Mark
Trahant: Appoint Indian to U.S. Supreme Court (7/11)
Key Republican speculates on Supreme Court makeup
(7/11)
Harjo: O'Connor trampled on
Native religious rights (7/8)
Republicans prepare for Rehnquist resignation
(7/8)
O'Connor resigns from nation's
highest court (7/5)
Justice's tenure
filled with key Indian law cases (7/5)
Supreme Court wraps up October 2004 term
(06/28)
U.S. Supreme Court vacancy impacts
tribal rights (06/20)
High court won't
take on Native Hawaiian recognition (06/14)
Appeals court to rehear tribal jurisdiction
case (06/08)
Tribal authority over all
Indians still unsettled question (06/23)
Myers not included in compromise on Bush judges
(05/24)
Tribal sovereignty must be
respected, court rules (05/13)
Supreme
Court Roundup: Indian law cases rejected (04/19)
Supreme Court refuses Bush appeal of trust case
(04/19)
Supreme Court takes drug case tied
to peyote use (04/19)
Indian lawyer
cites 'hostile' atmosphere in Washington (04/15)
Contracts still an issue despite Supreme Court
win (04/14)
Oneida Nation begins
land-into-trust process (04/13)
Supreme
Court to weigh appeal of trust lawsuit (04/07)
Supreme Court Roundup: Indian law cases
rejected (04/19)
Appeals court revives
Wind River royalty fraud case (04/07)
BIA official calls high court ruling 'quite
depressing' (03/31)
Supreme Court
overturns Oneida Nation case (03/30)
Tribes win decision in contract support cost
case (03/02)
Supreme Court takes on
tribal-state tax dispute (03/01)
Passage
of time at issue in Oneida Nation case (01/12)
Supreme Court rejects two Indian law cases
(1/12)
U.S. Supreme Court decides cases
without Rehnquist (12/14)
U.S. Supreme
Court asked to rule on state taxation (12/02)
Peabody takes coal lease dispute to high court
(12/01)
Tribal contracts pose conflict
for U.S. Supreme Court (11/10)
Court to
hear self-determination contract case (11/9)
Supreme Court takes action on Indian law cases
(11/02)
Mille Lacs diminishment case before
Supreme Court (10/22)
South Dakota
challenge to tribes rejected by high court (10/19)
Supreme Court Roundup: 2003-2004 Term (07/08)
Supreme Court affirms tribal powers over all
Indians (04/20)
Supreme Court to
resolve self-determination dispute (03/23)
Cantwell stresses importance of judicial picks
(6/17)
Tribal fears in Supreme Court case go
unrealized (5/20)
Supreme Court case too
close to call for some (4/1)
Supreme
Court tussles with tribal sovereignty case (4/1)
Supreme Court case pits tribes against states
(3/31)
Supreme Court panel's predictions
mostly came true (3/19)
Appeals
court nominees draw fire (1/30)
Bush pick worked on Hicks case
(1/30)
Venetie foe up for
appeals court again (01/08)
Bush
nominee familiar with Indian law (5/9)
Indian Law and the Supreme Court
(12/11)
Stay Connected
Contact Us
indianz@indianz.com202 630 8439 (THEZ)
Search
Top Stories
Trending in News
1 Tribes rush to respond to new coronavirus emergency created by Trump administration
2 'At this rate the entire tribe will be extinct': Zuni Pueblo sees COVID-19 cases double as first death is confirmed
3 Arne Vainio: 'A great sickness has been visited upon us as human beings'
4 Arne Vainio: Zoongide'iwin is the Ojibwe word for courage
5 Cayuga Nation's division leads to a 'human rights catastrophe'
2 'At this rate the entire tribe will be extinct': Zuni Pueblo sees COVID-19 cases double as first death is confirmed
3 Arne Vainio: 'A great sickness has been visited upon us as human beings'
4 Arne Vainio: Zoongide'iwin is the Ojibwe word for courage
5 Cayuga Nation's division leads to a 'human rights catastrophe'
More Stories
Litefoot shares positive message on Rez tour Ousted Fort Peck chairman wins re-election
News Archive
2018 | 2017 | 2016 | 2015 | 2014 | 2013 | 2012 | 2011 | 2010 | 2009 | 2008 | 2007 | 2006 | 2005 | 2004 | 2003 | 2002 | 2001 | 2000