Cobell Lawsuit & Settlement

Cobell critic files objection to $3.4B trust fund settlement

Kimberly Craven, a member of the Sisseton Wahpeton Oyate in South Dakota, has filed an objection to the $3.4 billion Indian trust fund settlement.

Craven says the attorneys who handled the case for 14 years are seeking too much money. Her objection questions the billing records submitted by attorneys like Dennis Gingold.

"The request for $237 million for the attorneys and class representatives might be excusable if class counsel and [lead plaintiff Elouise] Cobell had any basis to assert that their litigation was successful," the objection states. "They do not. The last four years of litigation, a product of the greed of class counsel, have been disastrous for the class."

As for the deal itself, Craven says it isn't fair to Indian beneficiaries. Most of her objections center on the Trust Administration Class, which resolves mismanagement claims against the federal government.

Beneficiaries can opt out of the Trust Administration portion of the settlement. But Craven says the deal can't resolve claims that weren't included in the lawsuit.

The deadline to opt out was April 20. The fairness hearing for the settlement will take place June 20 in Washington, D.C.

Get the Story:
Objection in $3.4 billion Cobell Indian trust settlement (Point of Law 4/20)

Related Stories:
Lawyer looking for beneficiaries who object to Cobell deal (4/20)
Letter: Cobell settlement isn't 'stalled' over attorney fees (4/18)
Editorial: Withdraw bid for 'exorbitant' Cobell attorney fees (4/13)
Big turnout for Yakama Nation meeting on Cobell settlement (4/12)
Editorial: 'Excessive' request for attorney fees in Cobell case (4/11)
Additional meetings scheduled in Indian trust fund settlement (4/11)
Editorial: Don't let attorney fee fight derail Cobell settlement (4/8)
Cobell plaintiffs oppose Republican bill to restrict attorney fees (4/6)
Rep. Young threatens subpoena over bill on Cobell attorney fees (4/5)
Audio from House hearing on bill to restrict Cobell attorney fees (4/5)
Witness list for House hearing on bill to cap Cobell attorney fees (4/4)
Rep. Cole questions need for bill to limit Cobell attorney fees (3/31)
April 20 deadline approaching for $3.4B trust fund settlement (3/29)
Subcommittee sets hearing on bill to limit Cobell attorney fees (3/28)
Elouise Cobell discusses settlement at University of Montana (3/24)
Cobell attorneys host meetings in Alaska to explain settlement (3/23)
Oklahoma beneficiaries question payment to Cobell attorneys (3/23)
S.E. Ruckman: Indian beneficiaries look for answers on Cobell (3/21)
United Keetoowah Band assists members in Cobell settlement (3/18)
Michael Roberts: Investing Cobell money in Indian institutions (3/18)
Lawyers in Cobell case discuss $3.4B settlement in Oklahoma (3/17)
So far, a few beneficiaries have opted out of Cobell settlement (3/16)
Audio from Senate Indian Affairs Committee hearing on budget (3/15)
Cherokee Nation estimates 1700 might benefit from Cobell deal (3/14)
Rep. Gosar signs onto bill to restrict Cobell attorney fees to $50M (3/11)
Cobell team to hold meetings in Oklahoma to discuss settlement (3/10)
Cobell attorneys say fee request not a big issue in Indian Country (3/9)
Bill to limit Cobell attorney fees to $50M referred to committees (3/8)
Cobell attorneys criticize Republican bill to restrict fees to $50M (3/4)
House Republicans plan bill to limit Cobell attorney fees to $50M (3/2)
Key deadline approaching for beneficiaries to Cobell settlement (3/1)
Dorgan calls Cobell attorney fee request for $223M 'shameful' (2/25)
Editorial: Lawyers the true beneficiaries in Indian settlements (2/25)
Cobell attorneys facing criticism over request for $223M in fees (2/24)
Elouise Cobell discusses Indian trust settlement in New Mexico (2/10)
Elouise Cobell headed to New Mexico to discuss $3.4B settlement (2/8)
Elouise Cobell to visit Navajo Nation to talk about $3.4B settlement (2/4)
Cobell team holding meetings across Indian Country for settlement (2/2)
Cobell attorneys detail request for $223M fees for 14 years of work (2/2)
Notification process begins this week for $3.4B Cobell settlement (1/18)
Attorney fees an issue as Cobell settlement moves ahead in court (1/4)
Shoshone-Bannock landowner not optimistic on trust reform at DOI (1/3)

Join the Conversation