Editorial: Ruling on off-reservation casino ignores consequences

Monday, March 7, 2011  

"No one should be shocked at the federal-court decision upholding an Interior Department ruling that land near Glendale should become part of a southern Arizona tribe's trust land.

On Thursday, U.S. District Judge David Campbell ruled that Interior was legally correct when it decided to allow 54 acres near Glendale to become part of the Tohono O'odham Nation's reservation. The Tohono O'odham intend to develop a substantial casino-resort operation on the property.

The decision will be appealed.

As expected, Campbell ruled extraordinarily narrowly. It is of no consequence to the feds what the impact of Interior's decision may be.

Whether the decision dramatically affects the gaming operations of nearby tribes is of no consequence to the feds. Whether it destroys a tribal-state gaming compact is of no consequence. Whether it forces costly infrastructure demands on the local community also is of no consequence."

Get the Story:
Editorial: Narrow casino ruling ignores consequences (The Arizona Republic 3/6)

District Court Decision:
Gila River Indian Community v. DOI (March 3, 2011)

Related Stories:
Judge rejects lawsuit on Tohono O'odham off-reservation casino (3/4)
Another tribe opposes Tohono O'odham off-reservation casino (2/24)
Tribal gaming group remains neutral in off-reservation debate (2/23)
Judge vows ruling on Tohono O'odham off-reservation casino (2/18)
Judge hears suit over Tohono O'odham off-reservation casino (2/17)
New angle in feud over Tohono O'odham off reservation casino (2/16)
Another suit filed over Tohono O'odham off-reservation casino (2/15)
Tohono O'odham Nation sues Arizona over land annexation law (2/11)
Judge sets hearing in Tohono O'odham off-reservation casino bid (2/10)
Editorial: State unfair in Tohono O'odham off-reservation casino bid (2/7)
Tohono O'odham Nation pushes for ruling on off-reservation casino (2/3)
Arizona governor signs Tohono O'odham off-reservation casino bill (2/2)
Tohono O'odham off-reservation casino bill being sent to governor (1/27)
Bill against Tohono O'odham Nation off-reservation casino passes (1/26)
Lawmakers take up Tohono O'odham off-reservation casino bills (1/25)
Lawmakers target Tohono O'odham Nation off-reservation casino (1/21)
Hearing set in Tohono O'odham Nation off-reservation casino suit (1/20)
Blog: No fairness in Tohono O'odham off-reservation casino plan (1/19)
Tohono O'odham Nation updates plans for off-reservation casino (1/13)