"The settlement of the lawsuit between UND and the NCAA (Oct. 26), granting UND three years to convince North Dakota's Sioux Indian community that “Fighting Sioux” is an inoffensive nickname, is, in my opinion, the worst possible outcome of this long, silly and tedious controversy. The best outcome would have been for UND to accept the NCAA's decision (Aug. 5, 2005) or to have acquiesced after its first (Sept. 28, 2005) or even second (Aug. 28, 2006) formal appeal had been denied by the NCAA. That would have been something like good sportsmanship.
Instead, UND chose to sue the NCAA (Oct. 5, 2006). This effectively dragged the sovereign people of North Dakota (and our attorney general) into a nickname crisis. By suing the NCAA, UND declared that it knows better than the collective collegiate athletic community in America, and knows better indeed than the North Dakota Indian community, which quietly but firmly agreed with the NCAA's position that “Fighting Sioux” is racially insensitive.
The “settlement” not only prolongs a controversy that has already gone on far too long, and continues to divide and distract UND, UND alumni, Grand Forks and North Dakota, but now imposes impossible pressures on North Dakota's Indian communities. The settlement will create new and entirely unnecessary tensions between the white and Indian communities. Notice that the tense debate is being moved from its proper sphere (UND) to a completely innocent sphere (the reservation). This is a failure of leadership by UND president Charles Kupchella, if we regard leadership as the making of hard choices and not shunting them off onto people who are not responsible for the crisis."
Get the Story:Clay Jenkinson: UND nickname lawsuit victory is a cynical, pyrrhic one (The Grand Forks Herald 11/11
pwpwd Relevant Links:
University of North Dakota - http://www.und.edu
The Ralph - http://www.theralph.com
Fighting Sioux - http://www.fightingsioux.com Related Stories:
Standing Rock group discusses 'Fighting Sioux' (11/6)
UND spent $850K to defend 'Fighting Sioux' (11/02)
Editorial: 'Fighting Sioux' deal strikes balance (10/29)
Settlement proposed in 'Fighting Sioux' case (10/26)
Judge hearing 'Sioux' case was part of mascot group (10/25)
Opinion: Find solution to 'Fighting Sioux' nick (10/8)
Letter: 'Fighting Sioux' violates human rights (10/3)
Tribal views on 'Fighting Sioux' at issue in case (09/11)
Editorial: Arena tries end run on 'Fighting Sioux' (9/4)
Standing Rock veterans back 'Fighting Sioux' (8/28)
Column: Time for UND to let 'Fighting Sioux' go (8/27)
Sparring continues in 'Fighting Sioux' lawsuit (8/23)
UND spends more than $500K in 'Fighting Sioux' case (07/10)
Spirit Lake woman named to UND search committee (7/5)
North Dakota governor wants Indian for UND search (6/29)
UND search committee could include tribal member (6/28)
Editorial: Indian voice needed on UND committee (6/25)
Tribes left out of UND president search committee (6/15)
UND spent $430K to defend 'Fighting Sioux' nick (6/5)
Author rejects honorary degree from 'Fighting Sioux' (04/20)
UND to move forward with 'Fighting Sioux' lawsuit (06/20)
Opinion: 'Sioux' lawsuit could hurt North Dakota (6/19)
UND to file lawsuit over 'Fighting Sioux' name (6/16)
Opinion: 'Fighting Sioux' logo hurts students (6/16)
UTTC president urges against 'Fighting Sioux' lawsuit (6/15)
UND president wants lawsuit over 'Fighting Sioux' (6/9)
Tribal member named to North Dakota higher ed board (5/26)
Opinion: UND's divide and conquer on 'Sioux' (05/19)
Standing Rock Sioux Tribe won't back 'Sioux' name (5/5)
Editorial: Seek tribal approval for 'Fighting Sioux' (5/3)
'Sioux' and 'Chief' denied again by NCAA (5/1)
Letters: Controversy over 'Fighting Sioux' name (5/1)
Standing Rock chairman disputes UND on 'Sioux' (4/28)
Opinion: Native students at UND subject to racism (04/12)
UND to file lawsuit over 'Fighting Sioux' name (6/16)
Opinion: 'Fighting Sioux' logo hurts students (6/16)
UTTC president urges against 'Fighting Sioux' lawsuit (6/15)
UND president wants lawsuit over 'Fighting Sioux' (6/9)
Tribal member named to North Dakota higher ed board (5/26)
Opinion: UND's divide and conquer on 'Sioux' (05/19)
Standing Rock Sioux Tribe won't back 'Sioux' name (5/5)
Editorial: Seek tribal approval for 'Fighting Sioux' (5/3)
'Sioux' and 'Chief' denied again by NCAA (5/1)
Letters: Controversy over 'Fighting Sioux' name (5/1)
Standing Rock chairman disputes UND on 'Sioux' (4/28)
Opinion: Native students at UND subject to racism (04/12)
