The Chinook Winds Casino, owned by the Confederate Tribes of Siletz Indians in Oregon. Photo from Facebook
Erik Stegman and Shawn Fremstad take aim at The Economist over claims about gaming per capita payments and poverty among tribes in the Northwest:
[A]n article in this week’s The Economist is a reminder that we haven’t put the bad old days of racially distorted coverage of poverty beyond us. The article claims “cash from casinos makes Native Americans poorer.” According to the author, a particular problem is that tribes distribute part of the revenues directly to members—typically known as “per capita payments”—which encourages “sloth.” The article is accompanied by a photograph of an American Indian man in front of a slot machine, a grin on his face and his arm pumped in the air. Given research like Gilens’ and the long history of stereotyping American Indians as lazy, The Economist should have been particularly careful to ensure that it had solid evidence to back up its claim. In lieu of such evidence, The Economist relied on a few anecdotes and a single article by a private attorney published in a student-run law review. We took a closer look at the law review article that The Economist relied on and were not impressed. It purportedly shows that poverty was more likely to increase in certain Pacific Northwest tribes that distributed part of their gambling revenues to members than in those that did not. But there were only seven tribes (out of a total of 17 that the article focused on) that did not distribute gaming revenues directly to members. The total reported decline in poverty among these seven tribes amounted to only 364 people. The study contained no controls for any of the many factors that affect poverty rates, nor did it take into account size differences in the tribes, differences in the size and structure of the per capita payments, or other relevant factors. In short, the study is absolutely useless in terms of providing meaningful evidence to support The Economist’s claim.Get the Story:
Erik Stegman and Shawn Fremstad: Of Stereotypes and Slack Reporting Standards: The Economist’s Claim that Native American Gaming Leads to “Sloth” (Talk Poverty 1/21) American Indian Law Journal Article:
Greg Guedel: Sovereignty, Economic Development, and Human Security in Native American Nations (Fall 2014) Related Stories:
Economist: Casino per capitas make Native Americans poorer (1/15)
Join the Conversation
