Army report describes attack on Piestewa's unit

THURSDAY, JULY 10, 2003

A humvee driven by Army pfc. Lori Piestewa, the only U.S. servicewoman to die in the Iraqi war, was hit by "direct or indirect" fire during a March 23 attack before crashing into another vehicle, according to a preliminary report being released by the Army this week.

Piestewa, a member of the Hopi Tribe of Arizona, survived the accident but was "seriously injured," the report goes on to say. Without going into specific details, it only states that she died later "in captivity."

Posted online by The El Paso Times yesterday, the "draft predecisional" document provides some insight into the circumstances that led to the death of the 23-year-old mother of two. Hailed as a hero in Indian County, Piestewa was promoted to the rank of specialist posthumously.

"Every soldier performed honorably and each did his or her duty," the report states.

At the same time, investigators admit their assessment is incomplete. "This report does not answer all questions," the unsigned and undated document says.

The report does not corroborate initial press accounts, spurred by The Washington Post, about the ambush near Nasinriyah in southern Iraq, and the subsequent rescue of Jessica Lynch, 19, a friend and roommate of Piestewa, from a hospital. Lynch was riding in the back of the vehicle Piestewa was driving, the report notes.

But nowhere does it indicate that Lynch or Piestewa were wounded by Iraqi fire. The Post at first reported that Lynch was stabbed or wounded.

The investigation also doesn't confirm more recent accounts of the nature of the injuries sustained by Piestewa and Lynch as a result of the crash, described as "horrific" by Pentagon sources cited by The Washington Times. Other than to say the injuries were serious, there is no description of what happened to the pair.

Nor does the report disclose how Piestewa and Lynch were treated in captivity, whether there was any wrongdoing by U.S. soldiers, or whether any soldier should receive special honors for his or her actions. "All these matters are under separate investigation," it states. Rep. Rick Renzi (R-Ariz.) has told The Arizona Republic that Piestewa died courageously.

The document does describe how an 18-vehicle convoy got lost, due to a "navigational error," in Nasinriyah and how the soldiers defended themselves from attack. Most of those involved, including Piestewa, were from the the 507th Maintenance Company out of Fort Bliss in Texas.

"Soldiers fight as they are trained to fight," the report's executive summary reads. "Once engaged in battle, the soldiers of the 507th Maintenance Company fought hard. They fought the best they could until there was no longer a means to resist. They defeated ambushes, overcame hastily-prepared enemy obstacles, defended one another, provided life-saving aid, and inflicted casualties on the enemy."

Piestewa grew up in Tuba City, Arizona, a town on the Navajo Reservation and near the Hopi Reservation. She was deployed to Iraq earlier this year.

"Specialist Piestewa . . . as well as many Native American women who enlist in various branches of the military, joined because of one reason that unites us all," Hopi Chairman Wayne Taylor Jr. said at a Memorial Day ceremony at Arlington National Cemetery. "They were Americans. Americans who simply answered the call of duty."

Get the Report:
Executive Summary | Full Report [consists of scanned document pages]

Related Stories:
Army to release report on Piestewa ambush in Iraq (7/9)
Ariz. board votes in favor of Piestewa Peak again (07/03)
Piestewa family honored at Bighorn ceremony (6/26)
Piestewa family honored guests for Crow Days (6/20)
Lori Piestewa: 'Hell yeah, I've taken fire!' (6/19)
Report: Piestewa died at Iraqi hospital (6/18)
Piestewa family honored on Memorial Day (5/27)
Military official says Piestewa fought with courage (05/27)
Military completes report on Piestewa death (5/23)
Piestewa to be featured in veterans exhibit (5/21)
Ariz. senate panel OKs Piestewa 'pressure' bill (05/14)
U.S. board won't act on Piestewa Peak until 2008 (5/9)
First Lady meets Piestewa family on Navajo visit (5/9)
So how do you really pronounce Piestewa? (5/9)
Ariz. lawmakers respond to Piestewa Peak flap (5/8)
First Lady Laura Bush to visit Navajo Nation (5/7)
Tribal jail inmates reach out to Piestewa family (5/5)
Opinion: Show respect for Piestewa Peak (5/5)
Squaw Peak highway changed in honor of Piestewa (5/2)
Ariz. GOP still steamed over name change (5/2)
Renzi: Piestewa fought to save lives of others (5/1)
Ariz. board to vote on Squaw Peak Freeway (4/30)
Hopi Tribe holds ceremony in honor of Piestewa (4/28)
AICF creates scholarship fund in Piestewa's honor (4/28)
Oneida Nation students raise money for Piestewa (4/28)
Column: Squaw Peak changed with little debate (4/28)
Piestewa remembered in Ariz. candlelight ceremony (4/25)
Navajo Nation council honors Lori Piestewa (4/25)
Editorial: Renaming Squaw Peak was right move (4/25)
Renzi also says Piestewa fought 'to the death' (4/24)
Concert to benefit Lori Piestewa's children (4/24)
Column: Lori died because she had no options (4/24)
Column: Piestewa fought Iraqi attackers (4/23)
Editorial: Don't throw rocks over Piestewa Peak (4/23)
Squaw Peak name change being contested (4/23)
Ariz. governor faces fallout for Piestewa Peak (4/22)
Jodi Rave: Don't call Indian women 'squaw' (4/22)
Readers still want to talk about Squaw Peak (4/22)
Ariz. paper profiles Lori Piestewa's short life (4/21)
Column: We wouldn't rename peak for White man (4/21)
Readers praise, critique Squaw Peak name change (4/21)
Say goodbye to Squaw Peak in Ariz. (4/18)
Benson's View: Piestewa Peak vs. Pipsqueak (4/18)
Ariz. panel votes to change 'squaw' names (4/18)
Republic Editorial: 'They did the right thing' (4/18)
Column: Lori Piestewa was not a warrior (4/18)
Column: Piestewa's name deserves much more (4/18)
Piestewa Peak views continue to roll in (4/18)
Some Ariz. GOP unhappy with Piestewa plans (4/17)
Editorial: Don't wait five years to change name (4/17)
Pequot tribe donates scholarship to family (4/17)
Column: What's Better - Squaw Peak or Piestewa Peak? (4/17)
More support and opposition for Piestewa Peak (4/17)
Hopi Tribe to honor Piestewa in official ceremony (4/16)
Thousands remember Piestewa in memorial service (4/14)
Editorial: Stop making excuses for Squaw Peak (4/14)
Navajo lawmakers cite poor timing for name change (4/14)
More reaction to renaming peak for Piestewa (4/14)
Piestewa service to take place in Tuba City (4/11)
Piestewa, the Lady Warrior, honored at pow-wow (4/11)
More opinions on renaming peak for Piestewa (4/11)
Reaction: 'One of the Fallen Heroes' (4/10)
Piestewa story extends beyond Indian Country (4/10)
Don't expect Piestewa Peak any time soon (4/10)
Column: Name change is more than just symbolism (4/10)
Footnotes to a war: What about Private Lori? (4/10)
How to Donate to Lori Piestewa Memorial Fund (4/9)
Editorial: Rename Ariz. peak in honor of Piestewa (4/8)
Column: Would anyone call Piestewa a 'squaw'? (4/8)
Piestewa death investigated as war crime (4/8)
Memorial set for fallen soldiers from Ft. Bliss (4/8)
Snow in Hopiland heralds return of Piestewa (4/7)
DoD confirms Piestewa killed in action in Iraq (4/7)
Indian Country mourns loss of Native soldier (4/7)
Hopi Woman Confirmed Dead (4/5)
Readers react to Piestewa tragedy (4/5)
Letters of Support Lori Piestewa and Family(4/4)
Piestewa: 'When is his mom coming home?' (4/4)
Rescued soldier has no information on Piestewa (4/4)
Military begins difficult identification process (4/4)
Rescued soldier watched unit members die (4/3)
Fellow Piestewa unit member rescued in Iraq (4/2)
Vigil held in Ariz. for missing Hopi soldier (3/27)
Hopi Tribe prays for return of missing soldier (3/26)
Piestewa Family Letter: Thank you for prayers (3/26)
Ariz. soldier reported missing (3/25)