Law

Turtle Talk: More interruptions for tribal interests in ICWA case

Matthew Fletcher and Kate Fort analyze the oral arguments in Adoptive Couple v. Baby Girl, an Indian Child Welfare Act:
This first analysis will have two components. The first component is an account of how many questions each side received. The rule of thumb β€” the side getting the most questions from the bench loses.

I have two counts: the first being mere interruptions (as noted in the transcript) and the second being a more careful count of actual questions (and by questions I include interjections and statements).

Count 1 (total interruptions): Petitioner side (both Blatt and Clement) interrupted 71 times; Respondent side (both Rothfield and Kneedler) interrupted 72 times. Blatt (arguing 20 minutes, including rebuttal), interrupted 59 times; Clement (arguing 10 minutes, plus additional time granted by Roberts, C.J.) interrupted 13 times). Rothfield (arguing 20 minutes, plus additional time granted by Roberts, C.J.) interrupted 53 times. Kneedler (arguing 10 minutes) interrupted 19 times.

Count 2 (total questions): Petitioner side β€” 57 questions; Respondent side β€” 66 questions.

Get the Story:
First Read-Through on Baby Veronica Oral Argument Transcript (Turtle Talk 4/16)
Second Read-Through of Baby Veronica Transcript (Turtle Talk 4/16)

Oral Argument Transcript:
Adoptive Couple v. Cherokee Nation (April 16, 2013)

South Carolina Supreme Court Decision:
Adoptive Couple v. Cherokee Nation (July 26, 2012)

Related Stories:
Tribes gear up for big battle with Supreme Court's ICWA case (4/15)
Column: Supreme Court set to hear racially-tinged ICWA case (4/15)
ICT interview with Cherokee Nation attorney on ICWA dispute (4/11)
Supreme Court sets times for oral argument in ICWA dispute (4/2)
Turtle Talk: Guide to briefs in Supreme Court's ICWA dispute (3/29)
DOJ submits brief in support of Cherokee father in ICWA case (3/18)
Wisbar News: Possible brief in Supreme Court's ICWA dispute (3/8)
Tribes line up support as Supreme Court takes up ICWA dispute (3/6)
Blog: Supreme Court hears Cherokee Nation ICWA case in April (3/5)
Supreme Court to hear Cherokee Nation ICWA case on April 16 (02/14)
NYT Debate: Indian Child Welfare Act and the Supreme Court (01/25)
Supreme Court ruling could impact ICWA cases nationwide (1/14)
Analysis: Media fails in coverage of Cherokee ICWA dispute (1/14)
Supreme Court takes first Indian Child Welfare Act case in years (1/7)
Supreme Court considers petition in Cherokee Nation ICWA case (1/4)

Join the Conversation