Indianz.Com > News > Cronkite News: New policy bars border agents from trashing personal property
ACLU of Arizona: “I Had Nothing” — A Story of Property Confiscation at the Hands of Border Patrol
After scathing GAO report, Border Patrol agents ordered to stop tossing out migrants’ belongings
Wednesday, August 28, 2024
By Mia Osmonbekov
Cronkite News
cronkitenews.azpbs.org

WASHINGTON, D.C. — U.S. Customs and Border Protection has directed agents to stop discarding migrants’ personal belongings, after a scathing report detailing how medicine, clothes, cell phones, cash and identity documents have been taken by authorities at holding facilities and never returned.

The new rules classify legal documents, contact information and religious items as “essential personal property” that cannot be stripped from migrants. Phones, cash, medical documents and items of sentimental value must be stored, with migrants given written instructions on how to retrieve their belongings.

In April, the Government Accountability Office issued a report affirming long- standing complaints from migrants and their advocates, and documented hundreds of instances of migrants losing birth certificates, cash and clothing.

In some Border Patrol sectors, migrants have been allowed to keep no more than could fit into a small plastic bag, according to GAO, with the rest of their possessions discarded.

U.S. Customs and Border Protection
Migrants are placed in holding facilities in the United States before they are sent across the border to Mexico. Photo courtesy U.S. Customs and Border Protection

The American Civil Liberties Union celebrated the changes Tuesday, though Noah Schramm, the ACLU of Arizona’s border policy strategist, said he remains concerned because the rules don’t explicitly ensure that migrants get their belongings back when they’re moved to another facility or released.

And, he said, some might have to travel hundreds of miles back to the holding facility to exercise their rights.

“The risk there is that Border Patrol field locations will interpret the directive to only require that these belongings are stored, but not that they are physically returned to people on release,” he said. “You could imagine scenarios where Border Patrol field locations decide to hold people’s property back, and only give that (back to) people who are willing to make the often long journey back.”

In February, the ACLU and a coalition of immigrant advocacy groups, including Arizona-based ProtectAZ Health and The Kino Border Initiative, released a report asserting that CBP policies “systematically fail to ensure humane treatment of migrants and their belongings,” citing hundreds of instances in which authorities confiscated medicine, clothing, phones and money.

From Hope to Heartbreak: The Disturbing Reality of Border Patrol’s Confiscation of Migrants’ Belongings
Report: From Hope to Heartbreak: The Disturbing Reality of Border Patrol’s Confiscation of Migrants’ Belongings

The CBP directive reflects GAO recommendations to improve the handling of personal belongings and give migrants clear instructions on how to retrieve their stored items.

Under the directive, CBP “will allow detainees to keep as much of their personal property as their facility’s physical capacity, safety considerations, transportation limitations, and personal availability allow.”

Filthy clothing and other items deemed a health hazard may still be discarded.

Migrants have complained that border agents have been overly aggressive in enforcing the health hazard provision.

GAO cited an incident in which an agent took the backpacks and clothes from a group of migrants on grounds the items “could be soiled,” rather than assessing the actual condition of the items.

Government Accountability Office Report
Southwest Border: Additional Guidance and Monitoring Needed to Improve CBP’s Handling of Personal Property (GAO-24-106540)

For more stories from Cronkite News, visit cronkitenews.azpbs.org.

Note: This story originally appeared on Cronkite News. It is published via a Creative Commons license. Cronkite News is produced by the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication at Arizona State University.
Search
Filed Under
Tags
More Headlines
Native America Calling: A more meaningful Thanksgiving lesson
AUDIO: Republican lawmaker blocks Wounded Knee sacred site bill
VIDEO: Republican lawmaker blocks Wounded Knee sacred site bill
Native America Calling: Native in the Spotlight with Mark Trahant
VIDEO: Roll Call on Nomination of Patrice H. Kunesh, of Minnesota, to be Chair of the National Indian Gaming Commission
AUDIO: Business Meeting to consider the Nomination of Patrice H. Kunesh, of Minnesota, to be Chair of the National Indian Gaming Commission, S. 4643 & S. 4998
VIDEO: Business Meeting to consider the Nomination of Patrice H. Kunesh, of Minnesota, to be Chair of the National Indian Gaming Commission, S. 4643 & S. 4998
Republican ally of Donald Trump opposes pick for Indian gaming agency
Native America Calling: Substance abuse treatment remains elusive for hundreds of people after Arizona Medicaid fraud
Native America Calling: Remembering those who stood up to boarding schools
Alaska Native bills on agenda amid limbo in Congressional race
Cronkite News: Donald Trump’s Defense pick faces scrutiny in U.S. Senate
Native America Calling: What to expect on Trump’s first day
Daily Montanan: Drug trafficking ring targeted multiple reservations
Cronkite News: New law requires data collection on Indigenous health needs in California
More Headlines