Cronkite News: Bills to protect ancestral tribal lands from development advance

Thursday, July 18, 2019

House panel OKs bills to rein in mining around Grand Canyon, elsewhere

By Miranda Faulkner

Cronkite News

cronkitenews.azpbs.org

WASHINGTON – Democratic lawmakers beat back a series of Republican amendments Wednesday before advancing bills to restrict mining around the Grand Canyon and on tribal lands in Arizona and New Mexico.

In a sometimes emotional meeting, the House Natural Resources Committee gave preliminary approval to bills banning mining on 1 million acres around the Grand Canyon, taking uranium off the list of “critical minerals” and setting a 10-mile mining buffer around Chaco Canyon. [ H.R.2181, the Chaco Cultural Heritage Area Protection Act]

The approval came after three hours of attempted amendments by Republicans, who said the bills in their current form are doomed in the Senate.

Rep. Deb Haaland (D-New Mexico) is a co-sponsor of H.R.2181, the Chaco Cultural Heritage Area Protection Act, a bill that bars energy development on public lands around Chaco Cultural Heritage Area in New Mexico. She is seen here at a markup of the House Committee on Natural Resources in Washington, D.C., on July 17, 2019. Photo courtesy House Committee on Natural Resources Democrats

“The three bills we are marking up today are going nowhere,” Rep. Rob Bishop, R-Utah, said at the opening of the hearing. “They’re not going to be considered in the Senate. They’re not going to be signed by the president. We are simply spinning our wheels once again.”

Republicans said the mining bills will hurt the local economy while standing in the way of national and economic security for the U.S. as a whole.

But Rep. Deb Haaland, D-New Mexico, pointed to the cultural and sacred sites that would be protected by the bills, noting that tourism and outdoor recreation offer greater economic potential for the region than mining would.

“Grand Canyon National Park was responsible for $667 million in consumer spending around the park and supports over 7,000 local jobs,” she said during the markup, adding that a Bureau of Land Management report found that mining would only support about 295 jobs in the region.

Democrats on the House Natural Resources Committee voted repeatedly to reject Republican amendments to bills that would limit mining around the Grand Canyon and slow uranium mining, before voting to pass the bills out of committee on July 17, 2019. Photo by Miranda Faulkner / Cronkite News

More importantly, Haaland said, the measures will protect the health of area residents after decades of mining on the Navajo Nation left a “toxic burden” that shows up in higher risks of cancer.

“We cannot allow people to suffer from these preventable impacts simply to do the bidding of the mining industry,” she said in a statement released Wednesday.

The bills passed out of committee on mostly party-line votes, that followed mostly party-line rejections of 14 amendments, the majority of which were proposed by Rep. Paul Gosar, R-Prescott.

Gosar argued that the bill prohibiting mining on federal land around the Grand Canyon [H.R.1373, the Grand Canyon Centennial Protection Act] alone would mean the loss of up to 4,000 potential jobs and billions of dollars worth of economic activity and tax revenues for the region.

“It’s copper, it’s mining, it’s where you get true wealth to come from,” Gosar said.

Tucson Democratic Rep. Raul Grijalva, back row right, sits next to Rep. Paul Gosar, R-Prescott, at a House Natural Resources Committee hearing on July 17, 2019, where Gosar tried repeatedly, and unsuccessfully, to amend mining restriction bills. Photo by Miranda Faulkner / Cronkite News

The uranium bill [H.R.3405, the Removing Uranium from the Critical Minerals List Act] would reverse a Trump administration plan that put it on a list of non-fuel minerals that are critical to the nation’s economy and defense, and could be threatened if imports from other countries were cut off.

President Donald Trump ordered the departments of Interior and Defense to develop the list in 2017, and the Commerce Department last month released a plan for ensuring a reliable supply of the 35 minerals on the list.

Gosar at one point offered an amendment to rename the bill the “Enhancing Soviet and Chinese Dominance Act,” arguing that not having a ready stockpile of uranium runs the risk of making America dependent on potential adversaries.

“Making ourselves completely reliant on other countries like Russia, China … is exactly why this bill should be changed directly,” Gosar said.

But Democrats argued that uranium has no place on the list of “non-fuel” minerals the president ordered up and that there are decades of uranium stockpiles available for military needs.

Rep. Tom O’Halleran, D-Sedona, said in a statement after the vote that uranium mining “throughout northern Arizona has impacted the health and wellbeing of families across the region, and communities are still grappling with the legacy of this activity decades later.”

“We cannot allow these precious lands to be turned over to mining operations that could irreparably harm the area,” said O’Halleran, a co-sponsor of the Grand Canyon mining bill.

Grijalva rejected GOP claims that not all tribes support the bills, which he said have wide support. He cited a poll that showed the majority of those surveyed support a mining ban around the Grand Canyon and believe that protecting public lands and waters is essential to the future economy and quality of life in Arizona.

“There is national support and there’s certainly support from tribal nations from across this country, and in Arizona itself, considerable and strong support,” Grijalva said.

#KeepItGrand - Havasupai Tribe

House Committee on Natural Resources: Interviews with members of the Havasupai Tribe on the importance of the Grand Canyon

House Committee on Natural Resources Notice

Full Committee Markup (July 17, 2019)

This story is part of Elemental: Covering Sustainability, a new multimedia collaboration between Cronkite News, Arizona PBS, KJZZ, KPCC, Rocky Mountain PBS and PBS SoCal. It originally appeared on Cronkite News and is published via a Creative Commons license.

Recap: #KeepItGrand at U.S. Capitol - June 4, 2019

Happening Soon: Leaders of the Havasupai Tribe and the Navajo Nation will join members in Congress in seeking a permanent ban on new uranium development around the Grand Canyon. Webcast at 12:15pm Eastern. #Arizona #ProtectTheSacred https://t.co/rJ1O6XPU00
— indianz.com (@indianz) June 4, 2019

Happening Soon: Leaders of the Havasupai Tribe and the Navajo Nation will join members in Congress in seeking a permanent ban on new uranium development around the Grand Canyon. Webcast at 12:15pm Eastern. #Arizona #ProtectTheSacred #KeepItGrand https://t.co/rJ1O6XPU00 pic.twitter.com/tZvY2CUveY
— indianz.com (@indianz) June 4, 2019

“Everybody knows it’s a special place,” Rep. Raul Grijalva (D-AZ) says of need to ban new uranium development around Grand Canyon. “It’s a sacred place for many tribes.” #KeepItGrand #HonorTheSacred #Arizona pic.twitter.com/B0mH7HO35s
— indianz.com (@indianz) June 4, 2019

“Uranium mining has left a toxic legacy around Arizona,” says Rep. Tom O’Halleran (D-AZ) whose district includes Grand Canyon. He is cosponsor of H.R.1373, the Grand Canyon Centennial Protection Act. Bill bans new uranium mining around Grand Canyon. #KeepItGrand #HonorTheSacred pic.twitter.com/Wgk3pazEHj
— indianz.com (@indianz) June 4, 2019

“I know all too well the damaging effects uranium mining can have on a community,” says Rep. Deb Haaland (D-NM). Her tribe, Laguna Pueblo, had uranium mine on reservation. She chairs House subcommittee that will hear H.R.1373, Grand Canyon Centennial Protection Act. #KeepItGrand pic.twitter.com/h2RUL1Npmj
— indianz.com (@indianz) June 4, 2019

“We are in near extinction,” says Carletta Tilousi, council member from Havasupai Tribe in calling for ban on uranium mining around its homelands in the Grand Canyon. Tribe supports H.R.1373, the Grand Canyon Centennial Protection Act. #KeepItGrand #HonorTheSacred pic.twitter.com/qcME5ehSMW
— indianz.com (@indianz) June 4, 2019

“The Navajo Nation has suffered profound impacts from uranium mining,” says Vice President Myron Lizer. Tribe has banned uranium mining on reservation and supports ban on new development around Grand Canyon. #KeepItGrand #HonorTheSacred @NNVPLizer2019 pic.twitter.com/eoNcjYvbIP
— indianz.com (@indianz) June 4, 2019

A statement from Chairman Timothy L. Nuvangyaoma of the Hopi Tribe is being read in support of ban on uranium mining around Grand Canyon. Nuvangyaoma calls Grand Canyon the “birthplace of the Hopi people.” #KeepItGrand #HonorTheSacred #Arizona pic.twitter.com/tVrVPPyFmV
— indianz.com (@indianz) June 4, 2019

Havasupai Tribe: “Our protest song — no uranium mining!” #KeepItGrand #HonorTheSacred #Arizona pic.twitter.com/oxC0f5XLYf
— indianz.com (@indianz) June 4, 2019