Border Patrol agents watch Arizona National Guard Soldiers in 2010 as part of Operation Phalanx, which saw the deployment of 1,200 guardsmen along the southern border. The Trump administration says it wants to send guard units to the border again. Photo by Army Staff Sgt. Jim Greenhill

Cronkite News: Ranchers support Trump's plan for troops at U.S. border with Mexico

‘It’s time we get serious’

Local ranchers support President Trump’s plan to militarize border
By Fortesa Latifi
Cronkite News

NACO – “By God, it’s time we get serious. And if it takes the military, then do it.”

John Ladd did not mince words as he stood at the fence separating Arizona and Mexico, his face shaded by the brim of his straw cowboy hat. He is tired of being bothered, he said, by the “illegals and Border Patrol” agents traipsing across his property, which has been in his family for 122 years.

On Wednesday, the White House announced that President Donald Trump signed a proclamation to deploy National Guard troops from the four states along the southern border. Arizona Gov. Doug Ducey tweeted “Arizona welcomes the deployment of National Guard to the border.”

Ladd said he’s “100 percent behind” the president’s proposal, adding, “This illegal immigration deal has been an invasion.”

Ladd acknowledges that illegal border crossings are at an all-time low, as data released late last year by the Department of Homeland Security confirmed, but said one immigrant crossing illegally is too many.

Fred Davis, who ranches 25 miles from the border, smiles at the thought of Trump ordering the National Guard to the border.

John Ladd, whose ranch is just 10 feet from Mexico, said that between Border Patrol agents “and illegal immigrants, there's no privacy” for him and his family. Photo by Fortesa Latifi / Cronkite News
Fred Davis, a rancher who lives 25 miles from the border, calls President Trump's proposal an outstanding “show of force to Mexico.” Photo by Fortesa Latifi / Cronkite News

“Outstanding. Bring ’em on. Somebody has to make a show of force to Mexico,” said Davis as he leaned against his red Chevy truck, cowboy hat on and a toothpick in his mouth.

It’s not the first time, however, National Guard troops have been ordered to the border. Presidents George W. Bush and Barack Obama did it in 2006 and 2010, respectively. Bush’s Operation Jumpstart put boots on the ground along the border; Obama ordered National Guard air support to the area.

While guardsmen are on the border, they act as additional support to Customs and Border Protection, rather than taking a “law enforcement role,” according to Customs and Border Protection officials in Tucson.

Petra Falcon, executive director of Promise Arizona, which advocates for immigrant rights, worries about the idea of having the guardsmen at the border.

“Are our National Guardsmen and women trained to address what’s going on at the border?” Falcon said.

As for the motives behind Trump’s decision, Falcon thinks it’s less about border security and more about deflection.

“I think it’s smoke and mirrors,” she said. “I think he’s having trouble in his own party and in his personal life and he creates this drama to camouflage the things that he’s not getting done.”

In an emailed response to Cronkite News, CBP in Arizona referenced an agency-wide statement that CBP “has a decades-long relationship working with the National Guard” and that the National Guard will offer CBP “logistical support.”

More from Cronkite News:
Ducey welcomes Trump plan to send National Guard troops to border (April 4, 2018)

This article originally appeared on Cronkite News and is published via a Creative Commons license. Cronkite News is produced by the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication at Arizona State University.

Join the Conversation

Related Stories
Cronkite News: Trump wants to send troops to U.S. border with Mexico (April 4, 2018)