The Koshare Dancers. Photo from Facebook
New Mexico newspaper calls on a youth dance group -- known as the Koshare Dancers -- to stop appropriating the traditions of the Hopi Tribe and the Pueblo people:
The idea that a bunch of well-meaning Boy Scouts are honoring Native traditions by performing imitation sacred dances is beyond offensive. Yet, for decades, the presentations of the Koshare Dancers of La Junta, Colo., have been not just accepted, but praised. The Boy Scouts, every holiday season, perform the dances based on Hopi and Pueblo rituals at the Koshare Indian Museum (koshare refers to a sacred clown in some Pueblo traditions). The dancers have traveled to 47 states and three different countries, attended Pueblo ceremonies and even visited the White House. They believe — wrongly — that the Native community accepts their attempts at tribute. What they don’t seem to understand is that these dances are more than tradition, they are sacred ceremony, and to perform them without being part of the community of their origin is sacrilege. Imagine the furor if a bunch of Boy Scouts wanted to understand Catholic tradition, and did so by re-creating the celebration of Mass and the consecration of the Eucharist, all while crowds of people watched.Get the Story:
Our view: ‘Tribute’ by Boy Scouts no honor to Pueblos (The Santa Fe New Mexican 1/6) Another Opinion:
Robert Desjarlait: he Koshares and the Appropriation of Native American Dance (Intercontinental Cry 12/15) Also Today:
Hopis say Boy Scout performances make mockery of tradition, religion (The Santa Fe New Mexican 1/3)
Koshares cancel winter dances (The La Junta Tribune-Democrat 12/18)
Join the Conversation
