The
National Consumer Law Center claims the
U.S. Supreme Court decision in
Michigan
v. Bay Mills Indian Community affects the tribal payday lending industry.
By a 5-4 vote, the court refused to overturn its precedents regarding tribal sovereign immunity in a commercial setting. The center, however, claims the ruling opens the door for states to take action against tribal entities for conduct that allegedly violates state law.
"The game is up for payday lenders who attempt to cloak illegal conduct in tribal immunity,” Lauren Saunders, the center's associate director, said in a
press release.
The center cited language in the majority opinion that said states possess "many other powers" over tribal activities that occur beyond reservation borders.
A state, for example, could file suit against individual tribal officials in order to avoid a sovereign immunity claim by the tribe itself.
So far, however, states have not been all that successful in taking tribal-owned payday lenders to court. New York was able to reach a settlement with a payday lender that was owned by an individual tribal member.
On the other hand, the federal courts have held that
tribal lenders cannot avoid scrutiny from federal agencies such as the
Federal Trade Commission.
Get the Story:
SCOTUS Decision Proves States Have Power Over Payday Lenders Claiming Tribal Affiliation
(The Consumerist 5/29)
Supreme Court Decision:
Michigan
v. Bay Mills Indian Community (May 27, 2014)
Oral Arguments on the
Indianz.Com
SoundCloud:
Relevant Documents:
Oral
Argument Transcript |
Supreme
Court Docket Sheet No. 12-515 |
Supreme
Court Order List
6th Circuit Decision:
Michigan
v. Bay Mills Indian Community (August 15, 2012)
Related Stories
Opinion: Congress unlikely to act on
immunity after Bay Mills (5/29)
Tribes welcome ruling in Bay Mills
off-reservation casino case (5/28)
SCOTUSBlog: A rare victory for tribal
nations at Supreme Court (5/28)
Opinion: Indian Country can't declare
victory after casino case (5/28)
Supreme Court backs Bay Mills in
off-reservation gaming case (5/27)
Turtle Talk: Tribes dodge a major bullet in
Supreme Court case (5/27)
Join the Conversation