Indianz.Com > Indian Gaming

Peter d'Errico: Seminole Tribe embraces limits on sovereignty

Monday, October 24, 2016


It looks like the Seminole Tribe is about to secure victory in a gaming compact dispute with the state of Florida. But retired professor Peter d'Errico believes the tribe's approach to the dispute embraces the colonial origins of federal Indian law:
The Seminole Nation has a high profile in litigation about Indian gaming. In 1991, the Seminole sued the State of Florida under the U.S. Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (IGRA). The Seminole argued Florida had violated IGRA's requirement of "good faith negotiation," by refusing to negotiate inclusion of certain activities in a tribal-state gaming compact.

Florida moved to dismiss, arguing the 11th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution guaranteed state sovereign immunity from the Seminole lawsuit. The federal district court denied the state's motion and Florida appealed. The court of appeals reversed the district court, and held that the 11th Amendment barred the Seminole suit.

The Seminole then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to review the case. In a 1996 decision—Seminole Tribe of Florida v. Florida—the court agreed with Florida. The Supreme Court said that although Congress had intended IGRA to override state sovereign immunity, that part of the law was unconstitutional.

Now the Seminole are back in court, with another Seminole Tribe of Florida v. Florida lawsuit, again in federal district court—this time about renewing a section of the gaming compact the two parties eventually finalized in 2010.

Read More:
Peter d'Errico: Seminole ‘Tribe’ Embraces ‘Domestic Dependency’ (Indian Country Today 10/24)

Related Stories:
Seminole Tribe accuses state of bad faith in gaming compact talks (10/03)
Donald Trump hired firm to lobby for tribal casino deal in Florida (09/29)
Seminole Tribe seeks decision in Class III gaming compact case (06/07)
Seminole Tribe starts work on scaled back casino expansion plan (6/1)
Seminole Tribe still going strong despite lack of new casino deal (05/24)
Seminole Tribe drops motion after gaming revenues published (05/13)
Seminole Tribe seeks court order to protect gaming information (5/12)
Florida racks up legal bills in gaming fight with Seminole Tribe (04/29)
Judge agrees to delay trial in Seminole Tribe's compact lawsuit (03/29)
Editorial: Courts hold the cards on Seminole Tribe's casino deal (03/24)
Seminole Tribe turns attention to courts after casino deal falters (3/23)
Seminole Tribe seeks delay in Class III gaming compact litigation (03/10)
Editorial: A 'shameful' delay on Seminole Tribe gaming compact (3/3)
Seminole Tribe faces setback for new Class III gaming compact (3/2)
Seminole Tribe wins ruling in employment case due to immunity (02/25)
Seminole Tribe's gaming compact takes a step forward in Florida (02/10)
Seminole Tribe plans $1.8B in gaming projects with new compact (02/01)
Seminole Tribe runs ad touting $3B in revenues in casino compact (01/27)
Seminole Tribe finally gets response to gaming compact lawsuit (1/26)