A divided appeals court on Wednesday upheld the murder conviction and death sentence for a Navajo man in a controversial case that was an issue in the Bush administration's firing
of a U.S. Attorney.
By a 2-1 vote, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals refused to overturn Lezmond Mitchell's conviction and punishment for killing a 63-year-old woman and her 9-year-old granddaughter. The October 2001 crime occurred just months after Paul Charlton began serving as
U.S. Attorney in Arizona.
Though it was one of his most high-profile cases, Charlton refused to seek the death penalty for Mitchell, citing the Navajo Nation's official stance against capital punishment. But he was overruled by political appointees in Washington, D.C.
Charlton's resistance, along with his views on drug trafficking and violent crime in Indian Country, was later used against him when he was fired in December 2006. Documents show that aides to outgoing U.S. Attorney General Alberto Gonzales treated him with disdain when he sought to discuss a second death penalty case in which he was overruled.
The highly-charged nature of the dispute is underscored by the unusually lengthy opinion from the 9th Circuit -- 102 pages for the majority and 30 pages for the dissent. Tribal and federal law enforcement authorities collaborated on the investigation, which was solved in a matter of
Mitchell raised a number of challenges in his appeal, including collusion between tribal and federal authorities to deny him his constitutional rights, improper exclusion of jurors based on race and misconduct by the assistant U.S. attorneys who handled the trial. He also argued that he couldn't be sentenced to death due to the Navajo Nation's objections.
The majority of the 9th Circuit rejected all of the challenges. The two judges said prosecutors
were just in seeking the death penalty because Mitchell's crime involved carjacking and
the crossing of state lines.
"We recognize that the Navajo Nation opposes the death penalty on cultural and religious grounds," Judge Pamela Ann Rymer, a Republican appointee, wrote. "We cannot say, however, that ideological opposition to the death penalty by its own force exempts tribal members from the reach of federal criminal laws, or overrides the presumption that federal criminal laws of nationwide applicability apply to Indian tribes."
In a dissent, Stephen Reinhardt, a Democratic appointee, agreed with the majority on many points. But he said "cumulative error" in Mitchell's trial and sentencing warranted reversal of
the conviction and the death penalty.
Reinhardt cited collusion between tribal and federal authorities, improper exclusion of jurors,
Mitchell's absence from the death penalty proceedings and biased statements by the assistant U.S. attorneys. Charlton did not make the opening or closing arguments at issue in the appeal.
Taking everything into account, "each of the errors discussed above combined to prejudice Mitchell with respect to the jury’s final determination to impose the death penalty," Reinhardt wrote. He said he would order a new trial and, if Mitchell were convicted again, for a new
At the time of the case, John Ashcroft was serving as U.S. Attorney General. According to Charlton, he adequately discussed his objections to the death penalty to Ashcroft's aides in Washington, even though he was eventually overruled.
But after Gonzales took over, the situation changed. When Charlton sought to discuss
the death penalty in a non-Indian Country case, Gonzales' aides ridiculed him in e-mails and refused to let him explain his views.
Those aides were responsible for putting Charlton and seven other U.S. Attorneys on the firing list. Five of them -- including Charlton -- were prominent members of the Department of Justice's Native American Issues subcommittee.
An aide to Gonzales later testified that the chairman of the subcommittee, former U.S. Attorney Tom Heffelfinger of Minnesota, was also targeted for firing because he spent "too much time"
on Indian issues. Heffelfinger, however, resigned on his own several months before the prosecutor purge.
But his replacement on the subcommittee, former U.S. Attorney Margaret Chiara of western Michigan, was among those who were ousted. She has since accused Gonzales of lacking
commitment Indian Country, where violent crime rates outpace the rest of the nation.
Gonzales met with Michigan tribal leaders last month and said he was committed to justice on reservations. But less than two weeks later, he announced he was resigning -- on the same day he scheduled a meeting with leaders of the National Congress of American Indians.
"We must have better cooperation from the DOJ on Indian issues such as resources for improved law enforcement and criminal justice in Indian Country," said NCAI President Joe Garcia after his August 27 meeting. "I hope this is a step in the right direction."
Gonzales is set to leave office on September 17.
Get the Decision:
US v. Mitchell
(September 5, 2007)
U.S. Attorney, District of Arizona - http://www.usdoj.gov/usao/az
Related Stories:Briggs: Gonzales kept NCAI waiting as he
(8/31) Heffelfinger: Gonzales was
open to Indian issues
resigns as head of Department of Justice
(8/27) Gonzales cites commitment to Indian Country
(08/15)Fired U.S. Attorney overruled on
(6/28)DOJ denies US
Attorneys were fired for Indian work
(6/22) Gonzales under investigation for meeting with aide
(6/15) Gonzales not committed to Indian
(6/13) No-confidence vote
against Gonzales blocked
(6/12)Editorial: DOJ firing squad targets Indian Country
(6/8) Top DOJ aide denies Native voting
(6/6)DOJ cut off Indian voting
rights probe in Minnesota
Earth chairwoman seeks ouster of Gonzales
(5/30) NCAI concerned about DOJ's commitment to tribes
(5/29)Heffelfinger supports probe into
(5/25) Ex-DOJ aide cites
'concern' about Indian focus
U.S. Attorney of New Mexico has Native roots
(5/22) Sen. Tester calls on U.S. Attorney to resign
(05/03)U.S. Attorney in Montana protected by
(5/2)Heffelfinger was a
target in U.S. Attorney purge
(4/27) Sen. Coburn tells Gonzales to resign over firings
(4/20) Attorney firings reviewed at
(4/20) Senate panel moves
Gonzales testimony to Thursday
(4/17) House committee hits Gonzales with first subpoena
(4/11) Indian Country crime an issue in
US Attorney firing
(4/2) Opinion: Fired
U.S. Attorney helped Michigan tribes
(3/30) Documents shed light on US Attorney firings
(3/20) E-mails shed new details on US
Attorney for Arizona
Domenici hires law firm over US Attorney flap
(3/8) Ousted US Attorneys to testify before House panel
(3/2) Ousted US Attorney cites
(3/1) US Attorney
ousted over tribal death penalty cases
(2/19) Hopi woman passed over for interim US Attorney
(2/1) Hopi woman touted as next US
Attorney for Arizona
Jones: Navajo Nation debates death penalty
(1/18)Bush urged to nominate Hopi woman for U.S.
(01/05) Heffelfinger: Tribes
need homeland security funds
gaming law proposal undergoes big changes
(02/28) Tom Heffelfinger to step down as U.S. Attorney
(02/15) Tribal leaders attend meeting on Red
(02/01) Red Lake families
meet in private with Heffelfinger
(01/31) California tribes spar over gaming machine
(01/24) Louis Jourdain
sentenced to juvenile rehabilitation
(01/17) Gaming proposal moving forward despite
(01/16) Judge won't allow
access to Jourdain sentencing
(12/19) IGRA amendments tough on many, especially
(12/12) Judge to decide on access
to Jourdain sentencing
(12/02) Red Lake
shootings case not over despite plea
(12/01) McCain proposes major amendments to IGRA
(11/30) Louis Jourdain pleads guilty to one
(11/30) DOJ releases proposed
changes to Indian gaming law
proposes major change in Indian gaming law
(09/16) Heffelfinger praises actions in Red Lake
(08/24) Senate panel supports
NIGC on Class II rules
prosecutor seeks to change 'national shame'