After 12 years of existence, the Office of the Special Trustee has completed just three out of eight key reform goals, the Government Accountability Office said on Monday.
Established by the American Indian Trust Fund Management Reform Act of 1994,
the OST began as a small agency designed to oversee trust reform activities.
But since the start of the Bush administration, its budget has increased
by over 130 percent to $222.8 million and its staff has more than doubled.
Despite the massive growth, only two trust reform goals have been completed since
January 2001. One was the creation of a beneficiary call center, which became fully
operational in December 2005, and the other was the creation of
an Internet-based trust portal in May 2006,
according to the report.
The only other completed reform was the installation of the Trust Fund Accounting System, or
TFAS, during the Clinton administration in May 2000. The system, however, has not
led to an accounting of the billions of dollars in tribal and individual trust funds.
The 1994 law requires OST to come up with a strategic plan and a schedule for completing it.
"However, the Special Trustee has yet to provide the Congress with a timetable for
completing the remaining trust reform activities and a date for OST’s termination,"
the GAO said.
"The lack of a timetable for completing the remaining trust reforms has hindered the ability of the
Congress, tribal organizations, and the public to fully assess the status of OST’s trust reforms or to plan for trust fund operations once reforms are completed,"
the report added.
Though it lacks a schedule, OST officials are confident they can complete
all of their remaining goals by the end of this year.
These reforms include a risk management program (March);
a trust funds receivable system (November);
a trust asset and accounting management system (October);
an appraisal management system (March); and a
probate management system (June).
The Trust Asset and Accounting Management System, or TAAMS, has been a major
hurdle in the reform effort. To date, the Clinton and Bush administrations
have spent more than $40 million on the project, which has missed numerous
The land title component of the TAAMS system has been finished, according to GAO.
But OST won't finish validating the data for the leasing component
until December 2009, the report stated.
The data needs to be verified, or cleaned up, because it can be inaccurate.
Each regional office of the Bureau of Indian Affairs developed their
own systems to track ownership of Indian allotments.
"The land validation took about 1 hour per tract in BIA’s Southern Plains region because
there are about 12 owners per tract," the GAO said. "This validation requires more time
in BIA's Great Plains region, which has about 32 owners per tract, and in
BIA's Rocky Mountain region, which has over 100 owners for some tracts."
Under the 1994 law, OST is to provide Congress with a "sunset" date when its
work will be completed. But now that the agency has taken on additional
tasks such as land consolidation and managing all trust records, that may
not be a possibility under the current regime, the report noted.
Despite the challenges ahead, the GAO concluded that OST "is in the final stages of
implementing the trust fund management reforms that
the 1994 act required." The GAO recommended that OST provide Congress with
a timetable, a plan for future operations and a workforce staffing plan.
In response, the Interior Department agreed with GAO's recommendations and
said it will have a timetable by this June. But the department
took issue with the suggestion that it hasn't completed many of its reform goals.
"We estimate that over 50 significant or "key" reforms have taken place and estimate
that at the very least there are many more "key" reforms to accomplish," R. Thomas
Weimer, an assistant secretary, wrote in a November 21 letter.
GAO reviewed the list of 47 completed tasks submitted by Interior in response
to the report. But "while they are important
activities for the implementation of OST's trust reforms, we believe
they are not key components" of the reform effort, the GAO said.
"Accordingly, we did not revise our report."
Government Accountability Office Report:
The Office of the Special Trustee Has Implemented Several Key Trust Reforms Required by the 1994 Act, but Important Decisions about Its Future Remain
(January 2007) |
Inspector General Report:Allegations
Concerning Senior Officials of the Office of Special Trustee for American
Office of Special Trustee - http://www.ost.doi.gov
Related Stories:Ross Swimmer: Interior still 'working' on
(07/28) Accounting firm defends social relations with
(07/27) OST contract tied to
favors to top officials
officials awarded $6.6M contract to friends
(7/24) Ross Swimmer: Indian trust not about
(3/29) Tribes, states weigh lawsuits against oil companies
(5/8)Ross Swimmer: Indian trust not about
(3/29) Norton denies fraud or major
problem with trust
(3/29) GAO report
warns of billions in lost oil, gas royalties
(3/29) Tribes, states object to Interior's lack of
(03/01) Pombo starts
investigation of DOI royalty program
(2/16) Bush, Democrats oppose $7B royalty giveaway
(2/15) Interior to give away $7B in oil
and gas royalties
(2/14) Oil companies
fall behind on royalty payments
(2/10) DOI allows underpayment of natural gas
(01/24) Editorial: Interior's
endless charade on Indian trust
(06/10) OST fares no better under Ross Swimmer's leadership
(6/7)Bush administration won't give up
fight on Cobell
(03/18) McCain weighs
GAO probe of Indian trust debacle
(03/10) Norton won't testify on trust fund retaliation
(2/28) Lamberth takes action on Cobell
(2/24)Bush official won't
accept claims of trust mismanagement
(02/17) Swimmer admits some Navajo appraisals too low
(12/13) DOI was warned on appraisals of
(12/6) Lamberth critical of
Norton's 'bad faith' on trust fund
(10/25) Interior denies attempt to halt trust fund
(10/05) Bush administration
challenges trust fund ruling
(09/16) Appeals court takes on Cobell trust fund case
(9/15)Bush administration calls for end
to Cobell case
(04/09) Trust fund
special master alleges government fraud
(04/07) Cobell trust fund suit mediators announced
(4/6)Navajo landowners question BIA
agreement with company
(10/21) Retaliation alleged in firing of trust fund
(09/18) Court report finds
undervaluation of Navajo lands
(08/21) Navajo trust fund manager targeted in
employees falsified Navajo trust data
(06/11)Navajo leaders criticize upheaval at
trust fund office