Home > News > Headlines

Print   Subscribe

New Cobell judge has experience with DOI
Wednesday, December 13, 2006

The new judge for the Cobell trust fund lawsuit has experience with the Interior Department, though it hasn't always been a positive one.

U.S. District Judge James Robertson has sat on the bench since 1994, after being appointed by President Bill Clinton. In those years, he has several Indian law disputes on topics like land-into-trust, gaming and sovereignty.

But it's a recent case on federal recognition that tested Robertson's patience with the Bureau of Indian Affairs. He blasted the agency for failing to make a timely decision on the petition for the Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe.

"The people involved in making the decisions at the BIA have completely lost track of the whole concept of deadlines," Robertson said at a February 2005 hearing.

Robertson was so fed up with the inaction that he imposed deadlines on the agency. But rather than follow the order, government lawyers appealed and got it overturned.

The same scenario faces the judge as he takes on the largest class action against the government. Filed in 1996, the Cobell case has appealed nearly a dozen times as the government, during both the Clinton and Bush administrations, has sought to limit its trust responsibilities.

The effort ramped up during the Bush administration, resulting in the unprecedented removal of Judge Royce Lamberth. Government lawyers claimed he was biased, a charge they levied against two other court officials who also left the case.

Elouise Cobell, the lead plaintiff, hopes Robertson won't meet a similar end. She pledged to try and get the dispute resolved as soon as possible.

"We want to see this case resolved quickly," Cobell said last week after Robertson was assigned to the case. "We will work in good faith with Judge Robertson to end this century-long injustice that the government has done to Native people."

In his Indian law cases, Robertson has expressed sympathy for tribal plaintiffs. After being overturned on appeal in the Mashpee case, he continued to rail against the BIA and its management practices.

Robertson already knew about the federal recognition process from an earlier case he handled involving the Ramapough Mountain Tribe of New Jersey. He heard evidence of a leak to an unfriendly Congressman and alleged mishandling of documents but concluded the BIA didn't break the law by rejecting the tribe.

On land-into-trust, Robertson dealt with the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act and its application to restored tribes. He rejected an anti-casino group's attempt to block a land-into-trust acquisition for the Pokagon Band of Potawatomi Indians of Michigan.

Robertson heard more gaming-related issues in a lawsuit over membership in the Shakopee Mdewankanton Sioux Community of Minnesota. Some tribal members challenged the BIA's approval of an adoption ordinance, which would have spread casino per capita payments among more people.

In attempting to resolve the dispute, Robertson was careful not to tread on tribal rights. "The court is sensitive to the federal government's long-standing policy of encouraging tribal self-government and recognizes that this policy reflects the Indian tribes' retention of attributes of sovereignty over their members and territories," he wrote in December 2006.

But he questioned why the members who opposed the ordinance were excluded from Interior's appeals process. The case was sent back to the department for further review.

In a more recent case, Robertson heard from a small California tribe whose leaders have been embroiled in a leadership feud for several years. The dispute centered over the interpretation of a little-noticed amendment to the Indian Reorganization Act that was passed in March 2004.

Robertson refused to free the California Valley Miwok Tribe from federal oversight. The BIA refuses to recognize the tribe's governing structure and has pulled funding for the tribe's self-determination contracts due to the leadership fight.

Despite his experience, Robertson hasn't handled any trust-related cases. He came close in a lawsuit over BIA's decision to reject a lease for a hog farm on the Rosebud Sioux Reservation, but the case was transferred to a federal court in South Dakota.

Robertson has heard a number of cases involving administrative law, which has been a central part of the Cobell lawsuit. Most of these cases involved environmental groups who challenged Interior's decision-making. One case was a challenge from a coal company.

Assignment of New Judge:
Cobell v. Kempthorne (December 7, 2006)

Relevant Links:
Indian Trust: Cobell v. Kempthorne - http://www.indiantrust.com
Cobell v. Norton, Department of Justice - http://www.usdoj.gov/civil/cases/cobell/index.htm

From the Indianz.Com Archive:
Judge won't free tiny tribe from BIA oversight (04/21)
Judge quits court in protest of Bush spy program (12/21)
Judge blasts BIA for delays in recognition case (2/15)

Related Stories:
New judge assigned to Cobell trust fund case (12/08)
Cobell wins Impact Award from AARP Magazine (12/7)
Editorial: No hope for a Cobell-only settlement (12/1)
McCain staffer: No 'hijinx' during lame-duck (11/24)
Editorial: Another good shot emerges for Cobell (11/10)
Cobell says Bush kills legislative settlement (11/9)
Tribal opposition to trust reform bill growing (11/2)
Editorial: End federal management of trust (11/1)
Tribes face trust challenges from Bush administration (10/31)
Cobell attorney criticizes Bush changes to bill (10/27)
Staff confirms Bush behind Cobell proposals (10/26)
Bush seeks major changes to Cobell bill (10/24)
Senate committee holds more Cobell meetings (10/23)
Time running out on Cobell settlement bill (10/23)
Cobell sees parallels in Aboriginal wage theft (10/16)
NCAI to consider resolution in support of Cobell bill (10/6)
Bush assailed for 'ambush' on Indian health care (10/5)
Latest delay in Cobell settlement tied to White House (10/3)
Cobell: Interior mishandles Indian money too (10/2)
Navajo woman fights for trust fund accountability (9/25)
Senate committee sends Cobell letter to Kempthorne (9/18)
Interior delays Cobell settlement legislation (9/15)
McCain firm on $8B settlement for Cobell (9/5)
Senate staff to discuss Cobell settlement in Tulsa (8/30)
Cobell shifts appeal strategy to keep judge on case (8/29)
Cobell fights for judge in trust fund case (8/25)
Senate committee to discuss Cobell settlement (8/24)
Human Rights Magazine: Cobell, Native issues (8/22)
Editorial: Justice for Indian account holders (8/18)
Professor: Removal of Judge Lamberth a tragedy (8/7)
Cobell eager to settle Indian trust fund lawsuit (8/7)
Letter: Nearly $1B wasted on Swimmer's trust reform (8/7)
Editorial: Stop delaying settlement to Cobell (8/4)
McCain puts twist in Cobell settlement bill (8/3)
Bush officials asked McCain to delay Cobell settlement (8/3)
Cobell settlement bill 'dead' in Congress (8/2)
Time running out on Cobell settlement bill (7/28)
Editorial: It's time for settlement on Cobell (7/28)
Ross Swimmer: Interior still 'working' on trust (7/28)
Cobell issues statement on settlement talks (7/25)
Cobell settlement awaited in Indian Country (7/25)
Jodi Rave: Cobell worried about settlement legislation (7/24)
Mark Trahant: It's time for the U.S. to keep its word (7/17)
Editorial: Lamberth too honest in trust fund case (7/17)
Cooler heads sought in Indian trust fund fight (7/14)
Lamberth removed from Cobell trust fund case (7/12)
Lamberth is third judge removed by D.C. Circuit (7/12)
Cobell settlement rumored to be in the billions (7/5)
Cobell rallies for support on trust fund lawsuit (06/19)
Editorial: Give Kempthorne a chance on Cobell (6/15)
Cobell files contempt charges against Kempthorne (6/13)
Editorial: Dirk Kempthorne arrives in Washington (6/13)
Swimmer calls Cobell settlement 'reparations' (5/8)
Cobell: Settle Indian trust fund case for billions (4/20)
Cobell to appear on C-SPAN Washington Journal (4/12)
Cobell renews call for receiver as court hears case (4/12)
Cobell vows fight to resolve trust fund lawsuit (4/10)
Cobell plans big showing on day of court hearing (4/4)
Jodi Rave: Tribes alarmed at trust reform initiative (4/3)
Cobell addresses trust fund mismanagement (3/30)
Ross Swimmer: Indian trust not about mismanagement (3/29)
Norton denies fraud or major problem with trust (3/29)
GAO report warns of billions in lost oil, gas royalties (3/29)
Witness list for hearing on Indian Trust Reform Act (3/28)
DOI trust reform meeting set for Portland, Oregon (3/24)
Kempthorne faces hot issues at Interior Department (3/21)
DOI pressed for more clarity on trust initiative (3/3)
Congress urged to settle Cobell lawsuit for billions (03/02)
Listening Lounge: Joint hearing on Cobell v. Norton (03/01)
Interior hits the road with new trust reform initiative (02/08)
Jodi Rave: Garcia calls for settlement of Cobell (2/3)
Cason slashes BIA budget and blames it on Cobell (2/3)
Tribes discuss trust reform bill, Cobell settlement (1/31)
Commentary: Swimmer still not telling the truth on trust (1/26)
Opinion: Indians want $12B of 'YOUR' money (01/10)

Copyright © 2000-2006 Indianz.Com